Monday, October 12, 2020

Michigan Gov. Gretchen Whitmer could be setting the stage to have criminal charges brought against Trump for solicitation of violence against state officials

Gretchen Whitmer
 

The right-wing militia plot to kidnap Michigan Gov. Gretchen Whitmer probably was a shocker to many Americans, But our "lawyer source," who we quote periodically on legal matters that are national in scope, essentially foresaw such an event six months ago. He also saw the potential legal headaches Donald Trump could attract for inciting such an event. News reports in recent days, our source says, suggest Whitmer is setting the stage to have criminal charges brought against Trump -- and, under the law, she has grounds to do it.

How did our source essentially see this coming? Let's turn to our post of April 21, 2020, with the title "Trump's words of defiance to protesters flaunt federal and state laws, sending a peculiar anti-government message from someone who heads the government": 

Donald Trump's recent Tweets, exhorting his followers to "liberate" themselves from state-sanctioned stay-at-home orders during the coronavirus outbreak, likely violate federal law, according to a former official with the U.S. Department of Justice (DOJ). Trump's actions also could violate state laws that criminalize defiance of lawfully issued state orders, a lawyer source tells Legal Schnauzer. That especially might be the case in Virginia, where Trump's Tweet included a reference to protesters' "Second Amendment rights," which could be construed as an incitement to violence.

While Trump clearly is playing dangerous games with the law, he also may be playing a wildly flawed political equation, according to New York Times columnist Maggie Haberman, in a piece titled "Trump, Head of Government, Leans Into Anti-Government Message."

As for lawlessness emanating from the White House, Mary McCord addressed that in an op-ed at The Washington Post. McCord is legal director of the Institute for Constitutional Advocacy and Protection and a visiting professor at the Georgetown University Law Center. She was acting U.S. assistant attorney general for national security from 2016 to 2017. From the McCord op-ed:

"President Trump incited insurrection Friday against the duly elected governors of the states of Michigan, Minnesota and Virginia. Just a day after issuing guidance for re-opening America that clearly deferred decision-making to state officials — as it must under our Constitutional order — the president undercut his own guidance by calling for criminal acts against the governors for not opening fast enough."

 

Our source then provided legal details behind McCord's words:

Our lawyer source provides details about state insurrection laws, especially from the Code of Virginia, and notes that states are not precluded from prosecuting a sitting president. Writes our source:

It is obvious Trump's tweets to protesters to "liberate" themselves from the "siege" the state governors have ordered was intended by Trump to encourage and incite those protesters (his base) to intimidate state governors. After all, wasn't intimidation of public officials the purpose of the so-called "Brooks Brothers Riot" in Florida in 2000?

You may find it interesting that the Criminal Code of Virginia has several applicable criminal provisions, including mob crime laws and criminal solicitation statutes. Also, the Criminal Code of Virginia defines a criminal "act of terrorism" as an act of violence with the intent to either "intimidate a civilian population at large" or to "influence the conduct or activities of a government, including . . . a state . . . through intimidation." Crim. Code of Va., Section 18.2-46.4. Trump's tweet was not violence; but the message Trump tweeted clearly suggested that Trump was encouraging protesters to act as a mob of public assembly and intimidate state officials to withdraw state orders issued to protect lives and public health. Therefore, if protesters, especially those known to revere Trump, end up forming a mob and engaging in any violence whatsoever, it is absolutely clear that Trump could be criminally prosecuted in Virginia for his public communications (tweets) in which he sought to command, entreat, or otherwise persuade persons to intimidate their state governments and state public officials and to resist execution of lawful state-government orders. If protesters followed Trump's encouragement and assembled, fomented riot, and/ or killed anyone, then Trump could be criminally prosecuted for criminal solicitation to incite riot, unlawful assembly, treason, and terrorism.

Virginia also criminalizes inciting a riot or unlawful assembly.

Finally, Virginia also criminalizes and calls it "treason" for a person to (1) solicit or encourage others to wage war against the Commonwealth of Virginia (e.g., insurrection or riot); or (2) solicit or encourage others to resist the execution of the laws of Virginia under color of its authority. See Crim. Code of Va., sections 18.2-29 and 18.2-481(1) and (5).

        The full language from the relevant Virginia law can be found at Title 18.2, Code of             Virginia.

          What kind of signals is Whitmer sending? Well, it's clear that she is unhappy about a plot that                  likely put her life, and the lives her colleagues, at risk. Consider this op-ed from Whitmer in                 The  Washington Post:        

When I addressed the people of Michigan on Thursday to comment on the unprecedented terrorism, conspiracy and weapons charges against 13 men, some of whom were preparing to kidnap and possibly kill me, I said, “Hatred, bigotry and violence have no place in the great state of Michigan.” I meant it. But just moments later, President Trump’s campaign adviser, Jason Miller, appeared on national television accusing me of fostering hatred.

I’m not going to waste my time arguing with the president. But I will always hold him accountable. Because when our leaders speak, their words carry weight.

When our leaders encourage domestic terrorists, they legitimize their actions. When they stoke and contribute to hate speech, they are complicit. And when a sitting president stands on a national stage refusing to condemn white supremacists and hate groups, as President Trump did when he told the Proud Boys to “stand back and stand by” during the first presidential debate, he is complicit. Hate groups heard the president’s words not as a rebuke, but as a rallying cry. As a call to action.

What does our source think of Whitmer's words? He thinks she's mad as hell -- and serious -- and she still has reason to be concerned about her safety:

I believe Whitmer is setting the stage so it's no surprise in about six months, after things cool down, when Mich. officials file charges against Trump for criminal solicitation and criminal encouragement of treason and violence against the State of Michigan and its public officials.

Thursday, October 8, 2020

Did contract dispute between Drummond Company and Norfolk Southern play a role in the head-on vehicle crash that seriously injured Burt Newsome?

 

Burt Newsome crash scene

The head-on vehicle crash that nearly killed Birmingham attorney Burt Newsome remains shrouded in mystery, so how does one go about trying to unravel the unknown? One possibility, at least for starters, is to look for connections between and among entities that are Newsome's recent courtroom adversaries (Drummond Company, Balch Bingham, Alabama Power) and an entity that is known to have a tie to the crash itself (Norfolk Southern).

Our initial research reveals one such connection, and it is curious, to say the least. The connection is between Drummond and Norfolk Southern, which probably should not be a surprise, given that Drummond produces coal and Norfolk Southern hauls freight, such as coal, around the country.

Published reports indicate the companies have done business for years, but the relationship has turned sour due to a breach-of-ontract lawsuit over the volume of coal to be transported to power plants around the Southeast. The case originated in the U.S. Western District of Virginia (Roanoke), with a jury finding that Norfolk Southern will have to refund almost all of $35 million in fees and penalties that Drummond has paid it. The case now is set to be heard before the U.S. Fourth Circuit Court of Appeals (Richmond), after a lengthy delay for post-trial motions. From a report by Angela Coker at the Birmingham Business Journal (BBJ):

A jury has sided with Drummond Coal Sales Inc. in a lawsuit the company filed against Norfolk Southern Railway (NYSE: NSC)

Drummond Coal, a subsidiary of Drummond Co. Inc. – one of Alabama’s largest manufacturers – entered into a shipping contract with Norfolk Southern Railway providing for rates to 23 specified coal-fired power plants from Shipyard River Terminal owned by Kinder Morgan in Charleston, South Carolina.

The nine-person jury determined NS broke the contract about six months after it was signed and, in a declaratory judgement, relieved Drummond of paying in excess of $40 million still owed on the contract and determined NS will have to refund Drummond all or virtually all of the $35 million it has paid since 2010. . . .

How did the contract go awry? Here is how BBJ described the jury's findings:

The jury found NS broke its contract with Drummond about six months after it was signed by entering into separate contractual dealings that devalued Drummond’s contract. During discovery, Drummond obtained NS’s confidential contracts with the utilities that own the plants and learned the terms of those contracts either required the utilities to use their own shipping contract or else pay liquidated damages, making Drummond’s contract worthless, and/or gave financial incentives to the utilities to purchase coal other than Drummond’s.

Norfolk Southern has claimed this was a case of buyer's remorse and that Drummond knew the risks, according to industry publication RT&S.

The contract contained guaranteed minimum volumes that, if not met, required Drummond to pay liquidated damages, and between 2010 and 2014, Drummond paid NS over $35 million in liquidated damages. The liquidated damages escalated each year, but over the term were between $7 million and $8 million. Other than a few shipments in 2010, Drummond has not shipped a single ton on the contract between 2011 and present.

How could this connect to the Newsome crash? The answer to that question remains murky, but we know this:

* Newsome has filed a $75 million lawsuit against Drummond on behalf of former executive David Roberson;

* Norfolk Southern, at the moment, is on the hook to Drummond for about $35 million;

* The driver of the SUV that hit Newsome, in a crash that shows signs of being staged, works at the Irondale, AL, office of Norfolk Southern.

How does all of this add up? Well, some key pieces to the puzzle remain outstanding. But the search for those pieces is ongoing.


Norfolk Southern

Wednesday, October 7, 2020

Alabama State Bar denied "permission" for Bham-area lawyer Greg Morris to get involved in my federal lawsuit re: "being jailed for blogging" in Shelby County

Tripp Vickers
 

A representative of the Alabama State Bar told a Birmingham-area lawyer not to get involved in my federal lawsuit over being unlawfully "arrested for blogging" ("The Jail Case") in Shelby County. 

Greg Morris, of Fultondale, agreed to attend a Rule 26 meeting (for scheduling of discovery) on our behalf and was rewarded by having U.S. District Judge Virginia Emerson Hopkins berate him in front of a room full of lawyers. Morris,on his own initiative, wrote an affidavit to explain his purpose for attending the meeting. While preparing the affidavit, Morris had a question that he thought someone in the State Bar's Office of General Counsel needed to address.

Instead of getting his question answered, Morris was told to stay out of my case. Perplexed and understandably taken aback, Morris passed along to me what the bar official said -- and I was not happy about it. Is it the purpose of the Alabama State Bar to tell a lawyer not to get involved in a specific case? I doubt it. Why would a bar official make such a statement regarding my case; does this happen regularly  in other cases? Greg Morris is a veteran attorney, with about 25 years of experience, and based on his reaction, I'd say the answer is no. Was I deprived of my right to counsel? Yes. Has the Alabama State Bar ensured that my right to counsel would be trampled in other cases? I think it probably has. Has it even communicated with federal judges to make sure I got the short end of the stick in U.S. courts? I'm having fewer and fewer doubts about that. For example, was Hopkins so mad at Morris because the bar told her that no one was expected to appear on my behalf, so she lost it when Morris appeared unexpectedly?

 How exactly did Morris' communications with the bar official go? Here is how Morris described it to me:

The State Bar tells me, "Do not use [the affidavit], it may just make your matters worse.

[The Bar official] said, "If they want you, the judge will call you or compel you.

I said I feel strongly about all I've written; he said, "You'd better not go. Now I'm not telling you to change anything in the affidavit; if the judge wants to hear from you, she will call you in.

How baffled was Morris? His words  tell the story:

I don't know what they are going to do to you, Roger. I can't imagine why they have such a hard-on. But the bar is telling me, "Greg, do not get any further involved -- you're not helping yourself and you're probably not helping Mr. Shuler."

I have to follow what the bar tells me to do. I wouldn't tell you this otherwise. I feel badly. 

[The Bar says], "Tell Roger no, no you don't have permission, you stay away from that, if the judge wants to hear from you, she'll let you know."
 
A lawyer has to receive permission from the State Bar to get involved in a case? That's news to me, and the whole experience apparently left Morris dazed and confused.

The State Bar, as a professional ethics group, is the lawyer's lawyer. My lawyer basically says, "Unless the judge asks you, stay out of it." He says no.

Why are they doing this? Why you?

 As for Judge Hopkins , she was acting like a rabid wolverine. Said Morris:


After she lambasted me, blistered me pretty good, she was so pissed off . . . I don't understand.

 I have these words from Morris, and more, in a word-for-word format.

By the way,who was the Bar official with whom Morris conversed? That is unclear because Morris does not remember his name.

 Douglas McElvy was acting general counsel at the time, and I asked him to investigate the matter. (The full-time general counsel now is Roman Shaul.) I see no sign that an investigation took place, although I've left a message with Morris to see if the Bar followed up with him. I've received no response so far

The Office of General Counsel consists of Tripp Vickers, Mark Moody, and Jeremy McIntire. McElvy told me that an inquiry such as Morris' almost certainly would go to him or Vickers -- and it did not go to him.

So, did Tripp Vickers tell Morris to stay out of my case? That's the best information we have at the moment.

Tuesday, October 6, 2020

Trump-appointed judge David Stras administered gross cheat job on police-shooting lawsuit, but William Acker's "railroading" in my UAB case was even worse


William M. Acker Jr.

David Stras, the Trump-appointed federal judge who unlawfully forced a finding of immunity for a Kansas City police officer who fatally shot an unarmed black man -- Ryan Stokes -- in the back, is an unmasked crook with a robe. But Stras' opinion in N.S. v. Kansas City Board of Police Commissioners (8th Cir., 2019) reveals that he actually is not as bad as a federal judge with whom I have come face to face in the Northern District of Alabama.

We are talking about William M. Acker Jr. (now deceased), the Reagan appointee who administered a monumental cheat job in my First Amendment/wrongful termination lawsuit against UAB (University of Alabama System Board of Trustees), where I had worked for 20 years. Evidence clearly shows I was targeted because of my reporting on the Don Siegelman case at this blog, but Acker took steps to ensure the case was decided with no facts in the record. (I'm not kidding).

David Stras
The U.S. Supreme Court, apparently anticipating that rogue judges like Acker would trample summary-judgment procedure, came up with a term for such an action; they called it a "railroad job."

Stras clearly conducted a "railroad job" in the Stokes case, so how could Acker be worse than that? Let's revisit  a key section of the N.S. opinion that Stras authored:

Some evidence supports [Officer William] Thompson's account. The police discovered a handgun on the driver's seat of the car, which could mean that Stokes was armed when he entered the parking lot but then tossed the gun into the car. And witnesses who saw Stokes running said that he appeared to be "holding up his pants as he ran," which is arguably consistent with Thompson's perception that Stokes was holding a gun. Finally, Thompson's partner claims to have heard Thompson order Stokes to "get on the ground."

Other evidence supports the family's account. No one besides Thompson observed Stokes with a gun, nor was any gun found on or near his body. The car's owner, who was Stokes's friend, claimed that the gun recovered from the car belonged to him and that it had been there all night. Moreover, some officers did not recall hearing Thompson shout anything during the encounter, and at least one officer thought Stokes was trying to surrender when Thompson shot him.

Notice the repeated references to evidence; that shows that trial-court judge Brian Wimes allowed for discovery before considering summary judgment based on police-immunity claims -- as he was required by law to do. Wimes denied summary judgment for Officer Thompson, but the Stras panel vacated that finding and essentially forced a ruling that found Thompson was immune from lawsuit.

We can give Stras a little credit for not trying to hide in  his opinion that facts had been entered into the record via discovery. What about Acker in my case against UAB? He allowed zero discovery -- meaning the case essentially was decided without facts -- violating U.S. Supreme Court and 11th Circuit precedent. Here is how we described Acker's handiwork in a June 2018 post:

How badly did Acker screw me on the UAB case? I've written several lengthy posts on that subject (see here, here, and here), but it boils down to this. He granted the university summary judgment, without discovery, in clear violation of the Federal Rules of Civil Procedure and Eleventh Circuit precedent, as outlined in Snook v. Trust Company of Georgia, 859 F. 2d 865 (11th Cir., 1988). From Snook:

"This court has often noted that summary judgment should not be granted until the party opposing the motion has had an adequate opportunity for discovery. . . . The party opposing a motion for summary judgment has a right to challenge the affidavits and other factual materials submitted in support of the motion by conducting sufficient discovery so as to enable him to determine whether he can furnish opposing affidavits. . . . Generally summary judgment is inappropriate when the party opposing the motion has been unable to obtain responses to his discovery requests."

Law doesn't get much more direct and simple than that. I filed at least three motions to inform the court that discovery had not been conducted, and Acker admitted in open court that he was aware of that, and I was entitled to conduct discovery to counter UAB's motion for summary judgment.

We've reported on at least one of Acker's judicial colleagues in the Northern District of Alabama who knows the law on discovery and summary judgment and has applied it correctly multiple times. We've reported that Acker himself has correctly applied the law in multiple cases. He just didn't do it in my case, and that's probably because he knew political thugs had pressured UAB to unlawfully terminate me, and Acker chose to protect those thugs. Specifically, Acker likely was protecting GOP cretin Rob "Uday" Riley and his associates, who were the driving forces behind my cheat job at UAB. We recently have uncovered evidence that suggests the Alabama State Bar might have been involved, too.

For good measure, we recently reported on Sarah Palin's ongoing defamation lawsuit against The New York Times, where the U.S. Second Circuit Court of Appeals, in so many words, confirmed that Acker cheated me raw on the UAB matter.

Acker did not just violate 11th Circuit precedent; he also pissed all over the Supreme Court of the United States (SCOTUS). From a case styled Celotex Corp. v. Catrett, 477 US 317 (Supreme Court, 1986):

We think that the position taken by the majority of the Court of Appeals is inconsistent with the standard for summary judgment set forth in Rule 56(c) of the Federal Rules of Civil Procedure.[4] Under Rule 56(c), summary judgment is proper "if the pleadings, depositions, answers to interrogatories, and admissions on file, together with the affidavits, if any, show that there is no genuine issue as to any material fact and that the moving party is entitled to a judgment as a matter of law." In our view, the plain language of Rule 56(c) mandates the entry of summary judgment, after adequate time for discovery and upon motion, against a party who fails to make a showing sufficient to establish the existence of an element essential to that party's case, and on which that party will bear the burden of proof at trial. In such a situation, there can be "no genuine issue as to any material fact," since a complete failure of proof concerning an essential element of the nonmoving party's case necessarily renders all other facts immaterial. The moving party is "entitled to a judgment as a matter of law" because the nonmoving party has failed to make a sufficient showing on an essential element of her case with respect to which she has the burden of proof. "[T]h[e] standard [for granting summary judgment] mirrors the standard for a directed verdict under Federal Rule of Civil Procedure 50(a) . . . ." Anderson v. Liberty Lobby, Inc., ante, at 250.

As you can see, there must not only be discovery, but "adequate time" for discovery. In my UAB case, Acker ensured there was no time for discovery. SCOTUS, in Celotex, seemingly was able to look into the future and see that rogue judges like Acker would try to skirt the law:

Respondent commenced this action in September 1980, and petitioner's motion was filed in September 1981. The parties had conducted discovery, and no serious claim can be made that respondent was in any sense "railroaded" by a premature motion for summary judgment. Any potential problem with such premature motions can be adequately dealt with under Rule 56(f),[6] which allows a summary judgment motion to be denied, or the hearing on the motion to be continued, if the nonmoving party has not had an opportunity to make full discovery.

Do I have no choice but to sit back and accept Acker's screw job, which the University of Alabama Office of Counsel facilitated with its silence? Do Mrs. Schnauzer and I have to accept multiple screw jobs we have experienced jointly in other federal cases? Not necessarily, as I wrote in a September 2019 post about the wrongful foreclosure on our home of 25 years in Birmingham:

If this were a case of incompetence in the 11th Circuit, that would be alarming enough. But this involves intentional cheating, which probably rises to the level of fraud on the court. And that, by law, should give us grounds to reopen "The House Case," along with all of the other federal matters -- including our employment cases against UAB and Infinity Insurance -- where we were intentionally cheated due to fraud on the court.


My initial research indicates a ruling grounded in fraud on the court can be attacked as void at any time, with no deadline for seeking justice. The con artists at UAB probably think my employment matter is way in the past, over and done with. They might be wrong about that. 

 

Ryan Stokes and his daughter

 

Monday, October 5, 2020

A partner at Balch Bingham law firm was an advocate for George Wallace's "stand in the schoolhouse door," blocking black students at the University of Alabama

George Wallace: Stand in the Schoolhouse door.
 

The late Schuyler Baker Sr., an early partner at the Balch Bingham law firm, was a principal advocate for segregationist Gov. George Wallace in his drive to block admittance to black students at the University of Alabama, court documents show. Is it any wonder Balch, with Schuyler A. Baker Jr. as partner and general counsel, would engage in a bribery scheme to discourage black residents in North Birmingham from having their property tested for toxins from corporate polluters?

Baker Sr.'s prominent role in trying to keep blacks out of the schoolhouse door at the University of Alabama is reflected in an opinion from a case styled United States v. George C. Wallace, 218 F. Supp. 290 (ND Alabama, 1963). The case caption shows Baker Sr. was in powerful company:

Robert F. Kennedy, Atty. Gen., Burke Marshall, Asst. Atty. Gen., St. John Barrett, Atty., Dept. of Justice, Washington, D. C., and Macon L. Weaver, U. S. Atty., Birmingham, Ala., for plaintiff.

J. Kirkman Jackson, Schuyler Baker and Reid Barnes, of Birmingham, Ala., and Thomas B. Hill, Jr., John Kohn and Hugh Maddox, Montgomery, Ala., for defendant.

Attorney General Robert F. Kennedy led the way for the federal government, while Baker Sr. was front and center for George Wallace and the cause of segregation. At the heart of the case was the government's request for a temporary injunction regarding Wallace's vow to bar the entrance of any Negro who attempted to enroll at the University of Alabama. From the opinion of U.S. District Judge Seybourn H. Lynne:

The facts developed at the brief hearing before the court on June 3, 1963, when this action was submitted upon plaintiff's prayer for a temporary injunction, may be concisely stated to highlight the emerging legal questions.

On July 1, 1955, Judge H. H. Grooms entered an order of this court in the case of Lucy et al. v. Adams, D.C., 134 F.Supp. 235, permanently enjoining the Dean of Admissions of the University of Alabama from denying Negroes the right to enroll therein and pursue courses of study thereat solely on account of their race or color. In supplemental proceedings, upon application of Vivian J. Malone and certain other Negro citizens of Alabama, Judge Grooms, on May 16, 1963, entered an order determining that the court's order of July 1, 1955, was still in force and effect; that it was binding upon Hubert E. Mate, who succeeded William F. Adams as Dean of Admissions, and that Negroes with pending applications for enrollment in such University could apply to this court for enforcement of the order of July 1, 1955.

Thereafter, on May 21, 1963, Judge Grooms heard a motion filed on behalf of eleven members of the Board of Trustees of such University for leave to intervene in the case of Lucy et al. v. Adams, and to modify and suspend this court's order of July 1, 1955, as interpreted on May 16, 1963. In their motion, the members of the Board appearing therein represented to the court that Vivian J. Malone and David M. McGlathery, each a Negro citizen of the State of Alabama and an applicant for enrollment in the University, were qualified to be enrolled under the terms of the July 1, 1955, order, but requested that implementation be delayed because of the prevailing climate of racial unrest. On May 21, 1963, Judge Grooms allowed the intervention of such Trustees but denied their motion to modify and suspend the order of July 1, 1955.

How did Wallace react to Judge Grooms' order? With defiance:

The Honorable George C. Wallace, Governor of Alabama, referring to the May 21, 1963, order entered by Judge Grooms, has stated and reiterated publicly that he will be present to bar the entrance of any Negro who attempts to enroll in the University of Alabama. He has also pledged that law and order will be maintained.

Thoughtful people, if they can free themselves from tensions produced by established principles with which they violently disagree, must concede that the governor of a sovereign state has no authority to obstruct or prevent the execution of the lawful orders of a court of the United States. No legalistic formula is required to express the craving of honest, hard working, God fearing citizens for a moral order logically supported, an attitude long ago expressed when Coke informed King James that there was a law above the King.

In the final analysis, the concept of law and order, the very essence of a republican form of government, embraces the notion that when the judicial process of a state or federal court, acting within the sphere of its competence, has been exhausted and has resulted in a final judgment, all persons affected thereby are obliged to obey it.

 The court made clear that Wallace did not have the authority to ignore its orders:

More than three decades ago, Chief Justice Hughes, writing for a unanimous court, declared:

"* * * In particular, to the process of the federal court actually and properly engaged in examining and protecting an asserted federal right, the Governor interposed the obstruction of his will, subverting the federal authority. The assertion that such action can be taken as conclusive proof of its own necessity and must be accepted as in itself due process of law has no support in the decisions of this Court." Sterling v. Constantin, 287 U.S. 378, 402, 53 S. Ct. 190, 197, 77 L.Ed. 375 (1932). . . .

Too well settled in the law to admit of persuasive arguments to the contrary are the twin propositions that the courts of the United States have statutory authority under 28 U.S.C.A. § 1651 as well as inherent power to enter such orders as may be necessary to effectuate their lawful decrees and to prevent interference with, and obstruction to, their implementation, and that the United States has standing to seek the injunctive relief for which it prays.

Judge Lynne ended with a plea for law and order, making it clear that Wallace and Baker Sr. were on the wrong side of history:

It clearly appears that unless an injunction is issued pending submission of this action on the prayer for final relief in a trial on the merits, the plaintiff will suffer irreparable injury resulting from obstruction to the lawful orders of this court and the consequent impairment of the judicial process of the United States.

May it be forgiven if this court makes use of the personal pronoun for the first time in a written opinion. I love the people of Alabama. I know that many of both races are troubled and, like Jonah of old are "angry even unto death" as the result of distortions of affairs within this State, practiced in the name of sensationalism. My prayer is that all of our people, in keeping with our finest traditions, will join in the resolution that law and order will be maintained, both in Tuscaloosa and in Huntsville.

 Here is "The Stand in the Schoolhouse Door," as recreated in the classic film Forrest Gump:

 

Wednesday, September 30, 2020

A second Balch Bingham partner steps down from a major position -- this time in Mississippi -- following the Burt Newsome vehicle crash in Shelby County

Burt Newsome crash scene
 

For the second time in roughly a week, a partner at the Balch Bingham law firm has stepped down from a prominent position. First, it was Mike Bowers resigning as head of the firm's Atlanta office. Now, it's Lucien Smith stepping down as chairman of the Mississippi Republican Party. Both exits come in the wake of a suspicious vehicle crash that nearly killed Birmingham attorney Burt Newsome, a recent courtroom adversary for Balch.

Mississippi Gov. Tate Reeves cited Balch's "entanglements" as one reason for Smith's departure. Do those entanglements include the Newsome crash? That's not clear for now. From a report at banbalch.com:

Lucien Smith, a long time Balch Bingham partner, was replaced as Chairman of the Mississippi Republican Party last week.

Mississippi Today reports:

Lucien Smith on Monday announced he’s stepping down as Mississippi Republican Party chairman, with Gov. Tate Reeves backing Coast businessman Frank Bordeaux to replace him.

Numerous Republican sources in July told Mississippi Today that Reeves, as new de facto head of the party in his first term as governor, wanted new leadership. 

And what polite excuse did spin doctors say was the reason Lucien was tossed aside?

It’s partly because Smith is an attorney at a major law firm that does millions of dollars in business with the state and Reeves believes that is untoward and wanted a chairman with no such entanglements.

"Entanglements" seems like a peculiar term to apply to Balch's business dealings in the Magnolia State:

With Bach’s reputation apparently in shambles, sources wouldn’t even mention the alleged racist firm by name.

Balch Bingham appears to have a bad stench even in Mississippi.

And curiously the business dealings are called “entanglemens.” Is there something the Governor knows that the public does not?

 

Lucien Smith
 

Tuesday, September 29, 2020

One of the good guys at Balch Bingham bails out in the wake of Burt Newsome vehicle crash, possibly signaling an exodus of the firm's best and brightest

Burt Newsome crash scene

Is the suspicious vehicle crash that nearly killed Birmingham attorney Burt Newsome reverberating in the upper reaches of the Balch Bingham law firm? The answer appears to be yes, following the resignation last week of Mike Bowers as head of the firm's Atlanta office.

Bowers, a former attorney general of Georgia, has a reputation as a corruption fighter. Did he become uncomfortable at a firm that might be connected to the Newsome crash? We don't have a definitive answer yet, but banbalch.com addresses the issue in a post titled "Former Georgia Attorney General Dumps Balch; Exodus of the Good Begins." From the post:

 

Former Georgia Attorney General Mike Bowers has quit embattled law firm Balch & Bingham. Law.com is reporting he has jumped to Johnson Marlowe.

Two years ago, we wrote about the Dean of Balch’s Atlanta office, writing:

We know about some of the great and honorable partners at Balch & Bingham who truly have been hurt by the alleged unsavory, racist, and criminal conduct by a few bad apples at the firm.

In Atlanta, a controversy has exploded over the high legal fees paid to a law firm to investigate a first-class junket to South Africa.

And who offered the most ethical, most honorable, most insightful observations on the matter? A Balch & Bingham partner….Mike Bowers.

Ban Balch does not see the firm as purely a landing spot for swamp creatures:

    We have always known there are truly inherently good people at Balch.

    In 2017, Bowers and another Balch partner were fighting corruption in Georgia. We wrote:

Two outstanding Balch partners in Atlanta have been fighting alleged self-dealing corruption against an”Atlanta attorney accused of using his position as a special prosecutor to force businesses to forfeit hundreds of thousands of dollars in assets from which he then allegedly drew his fees.”

According to The Daily Report, Balch partners Christopher Anulewicz and Mike Bowers (a former Georgia Attorney General) “contend that [Michael] Lambros uses his special prosecutorial authority and the threat of prosecution to orchestrate the surrender of defendants’ assets and that a court-ordered review of his escrow account records shows that Lambros paid his fees and costs from forfeiture settlements only after they were deposited in his firm escrow account. That, they argued, constituted an illegal contingency fee.”

Unlike their Balch counterparts in Birmingham that lied about the CDLU and then created a secretive Star Chamber to allegedly hide what appears to be unethical or possible criminal acts in the Newsome Conspiracy Case, Anulewicz and Bowers are fighting against corruption and injustice.

Would anyone with a solid moral compass want to stay at Balch?

Now that Balch defenders, stooges, and buffoons have disgraced the law firm even further, sensible partners appear to have had enough.

The exodus of good, experienced, and honorable partners at Balch satellites has begun.

As Balch continues to be left behind with what appears to be an embittered leadership team, inexperienced attorneys, and fewer clients, what will the moral of the story be?

Don’t vow to fight to the death with a sole-practitioner attorney who was almost killed?

Don’t orchestrate an embarrassing campaign that utterly backfired?

Don’t let a humiliating spectacle of uncontrolled stupidity overshadow the wise, the good, and the honorable?

Maybe all of the above.

We wish The Honorable Mike Bowers the best of luck as he says good-bye to Balch.

 

Mike Bowers

Monday, September 28, 2020

History teaches that shaky ethics are not new for Balch Bingham law firm, but ugliness might have reached an all-time low with the Burt Newsome vehicle crash

Burt Newsome crash scene
 

The questionable ethics of the Balch Bingham law firm have been unmasked for the public, most prominently in the North Birmingham Superfund bribery case; perhaps most stunningly in the head-on vehicle crash that nearly claimed the life of attorney Burt Newsome, a recent courtroom adversary of Balch and its clients (Alabama Power, Drummond Company).

Evidence from the scene suggests the crash might have been staged, perhaps designed to intimidate, injure, or even kill Newsome. He did, in fact, sustain grave injuries, but is recovering from emergency trauma surgery and has even made a few trips to the office. 

[We invite you to check the crash-scene photo above and note the SUV's wheels are turned sharply right, directly into the driver's compartment of Newsome's vehicle; a similar turn to the left might have missed the Newsome car altogether, or at least, placed the impact on the passenger's compartment, which was vacant. Does this mean the SUV driver meant to hit not only Newsome's car, but the area where Newsome was seated?]

Two big questions: If the incident was staged, who staged it? Why was a Norfolk Southern employee driving the SUV, many miles from the company's local HQ in Irondale? We do not have the answers at this time.

But we do know dubious ethics are not new in Alabama, in general, and for Balch Bingham, in particular. A Selma Times-Journal (STJ) article from June 21, 2005, shows that Balch was part of a political culture that showered gifts on public officials, apparently with the expectation of receiving favors in return. The gift-giving was international in scope, reports the STJ: 

State officials have taken free trips to Australia, The Bahamas, They've gone hunting for free. And they've been given top-notch tickets to Talladega. 

Balch reported spending $5,197 on hunting trips for Jim Sullivan, president of the Alabama Public Service Commission (PSC), to the Five Star Plantation hunting club at Kellyton in Coosa County. The PSC regulates Balch client Alabama Power, but Sullivan denied the trips had anything to do with Alabama Power. 

History tells us that Balch long has played along the edge of ethical boundaries. But just how low will the present-day firm -- with its historic ties to segregationist Gov. George Wallace -- go? If all the facts on the Newome crash become known, we might have a disturbing answer.


George Wallace

Thursday, September 24, 2020

As attorney Burt Newsome recovers from injuries in suspicious head-on vehicle crash, the ghost of George Wallace hangs over embattled Balch Bingham law firm




The late Schulyer Baker Sr., an early partner at the Balch Bingham law firm, was a noted insider with segregationist Gov. George Wallace. How much of an insider was Baker, whose son Schuyler Allen Baker Jr. now is general counsel at Balch as it wrestles with a number of controversies related to race? [The most recent controversy, going beyond race, involves the suspicious vehicle crash that nearly claimed the life of attorney Burt Newsome and reportedly has stunned the Birmingham legal and business communities.]

 Newspaper archives indicate Balch Bingham has played rough for years. According to a July 1964 article at The Anniston Star, Baker Sr. was the go-to guy when Wallace wanted to make sure Birmingham businessman Elton B. Stephens Sr. (founder of EBSCO Industries) landed a state textbooks contract.

That meant canceling the textbook-depository contract of Paul Malone (from Northport), who had held it for seven years, and shifting it to Stephens, a close friend of Wallace. Baker was the aide Wallace chose to make that happen.

Malone was not happy with the outcome, claiming he was the victim of politics. He told the press he had discussed with Wallace the possible sale of the depository to Stephens but felt Stephens' offer was too low. Wallace's response? "We'll wait and see what happens?" This is what happened: Thanks largely to Schuyler Baker, Malone saw the contract swept out from under him. Wrote The Star:

On Oct. 1, the State Board of Education (featuring four new Wallace appointees) canceled Malone's contract and eventually awarded a new contract to Stephens. 

Malone also told reporters that a Birmingham attorney, Schuyler Baker, who represented Stephens in the proposed sale of the depository business, told him in a telephone conversation that Wallace would cancel the contract unless Malone agreed to sell the property. Contacted in Birmingham, Baker denied it.

Malone showed newsmen copies of registered letters to and from Baker during the negotiations. Malone obtained an injunction to block the contract cancellation, but the Alabama Supreme Court overturned it, and the education board promptly awarded a new contract to Stephens.

Moving to the present day and controversies swirling around Balch, they might have recently increased by one when attorney Burt Newsome -- after court skirmishes with Balch and its clients, Alabama Power and Dummond Company -- was injured in a car crash that showed signs of being intentionally set up. 

Was Newsome the target of a hit? The Birmingham legal and business communities are "stunned and in disbelief" after the Newsome crash, according to a report at banbalch.com:

Burt Newsome has been discharged from the hospital and is making a steady recovery. The Iron Man has even gone to his office, defying those who may have hoped he was permanently silenced or crippled.

Leading activists, business leaders, lawyers, and judicial branch employees in Alabama are stunned and in disbelief that Burt Newsome was almost killed.

Newsome has received a flurry of support and “get well” messages from colleagues and lawyers, but not a peep, not a squeak from Balch or their henchmen.

Was Newsome a victim once again? Many think so.

 

Burt Newsome crash scene.

 

Wednesday, September 23, 2020

In an age of hyper-partisanship, famed journalist Bob Woodward is catching unfair heat for holding back Trump's quotes re: coronavirus for "Rage" book

 

Bob Woodward is taking unfair heat for holding back President Trump's quotes about the coronavirus for the famed journalist's book Rage (released last week) at a time when America's "ethical lens" seems to be foggy, according to a legal-ethics expert at Western Michigan University. Writes Victoria Vuletich: 

“People seek simple solutions to complex problems.”  So goes the adage.  The furor over Bob Woodward withholding the President’s early knowledge of how deadly and contagious the Coronavirus is proves the adage, and more importantly, illustrates the extent to which America has discarded its ethical lens.

Yes, had Woodward disclosed the President’s statements earlier than last week, lives “might” have been saved, and surely this is a compelling ethical and moral issue.  But ethics issues always involve a balance of competing interests, and it was Woodward, alone, who had to wrestle with them. 

        Woodward stated that he needed to determine whether the President’s statements about Covid-19          were true. In an age where misinformation, misleading commentary and outright falsehoods are           peddled as “news,” Woodward took time to practice integrity and honesty. Woodward refused to         print something that would have easily generated much publicity for his forthcoming book until he         could confirm its truth. Isn’t that what we need and want from those who seek to influence our             opinion? He surely had his reputation, built over decades, in mind too. Should he risk his voice             of credibility and authority by printing something whose accuracy he questioned? 

Would earlier release of the Trump quotes -- if even possible, given Woodward's book contract -- have made much difference? Vuletich has doubts:

An equally significant factor in the calculation is the context of the time. Representative Louie Gohmert contracted coronavirus after refusing to wear a face mask, stating: “I can't help but think that if I hadn't been wearing a mask so much in the last 10 days or so, I really wonder if I would have gotten it.”  Representative Tom Rice was the first national legislator to report having the coronavirus, indicating that he had no regrets about not wearing a mask: “My understanding is that a mask doesn't really protect you as much as it protects other people.”  Would these two men have believed what Woodward said in March?  Would the President’s base have believed Woodward in March?  Not likely.  A significant percentage of the President’s supporters would have accepted the President’s public statements and labeled Woodward’s tapes as “fake.”This says something about America’s ethical lens.

America has become a nation where we view most complex issues through a political lens.  We seek easy solutions to complex problems because the ugly hyper-partisanship of our current political process exhausts our willingness and appetite to engage in even the moderate analysis required to deal with the complex issues of our time. We align ourselves with a party, throw money at it and expect it “to fix things” without our engagement and involvement. 

Why look to simple, partisan answers to tough questions? Because it doesn't cost us much:

Viewing our nation’s issues solely through a political lens allows us to escape our ethical and moral responsibility. We avoid the painful task of having to ceaselessly reflect on the intersection of our personal moral values with the actions and policies taken by those we elect. We grasp at suggestions that “things can stay the same” or that “issues can easily be addressed without great cost” despite living in a time of unprecedented economic restructuring and global climate change, which bring unavoidable and painful consequences. 

Most frighteningly, donning only the political lens allows us to dehumanize the opinions, values, and fears of half of our neighbors, co-workers, friends and even family members.   We silently believe: “If only our side can win, everything will be o.k.”  But we know life does not work this way and never has - unless you desire civil war and an impotent government.

Would some of us have made a different call on timing than Woodward? Perhaps. Woodward did not confirm the President’s statements until May, long after the virus was already raging. Perhaps Woodward waited so long because he thought the harm was already done. But we must recognize and respect that he was wrestling with a complex issue that involved competing values, interests and social context.

Vuletich does see hopeful signs:

Encouragingly, the George Floyd protests represented a moment when America embraced its ethical responsibility. Ethical citizens from across the political spectrum demonstrated peacefully because they recognized George Floyd’s vulnerability and worth as a human being and responded, many out of a sense of epiphany. Individuals looked inside themselves, willing to change their previous assumptions and perspectives. Real change is slowly underway because of this collective embrace of moral and ethical responsibility.

It is human nature to seek simple solutions to complex problems.  If we fail to personally take responsibility for the ethical complexity of our political beliefs and systems, we will find ourselves as a society at the other end of this spectrum of human nature:    “. . . in the big lie, there is always a certain force of credibility.” An adage expressed by Adolph Hitler in Mein Kampf.  We are believing many small lies.  Let’s stop, before we become willing to believe a big one.