Monday, July 2, 2012

How Much Sleaze Will Be Unearthed In Investigation of the U.S. Chamber of Commerce?

Tom Donohue

The U.S. Supreme Court's decision to uphold most of the Obama health-care law was by far the most-watched story of last week. But a story that might prove to be more important in the long run quietly unfolded in Albany, New York.

It could wind up shining light on organizations and individuals who have befouled the political environment here in Alabama.

Eric T. Schneiderman, the attorney general of New York, launched an investigation of tax-exempt groups that are heavily involved in political campaigns. A case involving the U.S. Chamber of Commerce, and its high-profile director Tom Donohue, is a focal point of the probe. It might also examine groups led by the billionaire Koch brothers and  Republican strategist Karl Rove.

What could this mean for Alabama? Well, it's too early to say. But it's a matter of public record that Rove and Business Council of Alabama (BCA) President Bill Canary used financial support from the U.S. Chamber of Commerce to essentially buy state-court seats in our state. That process started in the mid 1990s and turned an all-Democratic bench into a Republican stronghold, one that has been prone to overturn jury verdicts that favor consumers.

It's also a matter of public record that Canary's BCA was linked to the political prosecution of former Alabama Governor Don Siegelman. And one of Canary's lieutenants, Ralph Stacy, died from a mysterious shotgun blast at BCA headquarters. Stacy's death has been ruled a suicide, but the details of any investigation have gone largely unreported in the mainstream Montgomery press.

We already have asked this question: Did the U.S. Chamber of Commerce play a role in Ralph Stacy's death? Should the New York investigation wind up spreading to Alabama . . . well, there is no telling what ugliness might be found. For now, here is how The New York Times describes the focus of Schneiderman's probe:

Mr. Schneiderman issued a wide-ranging subpoena on Tuesday to executives at a foundation affiliated with the chamber, seeking e-mails, bank records and other documents to determine whether the foundation illegally funneled $18 million to the chamber for political and lobbying activities, according to people with knowledge of the investigation.

The investigation is also looking at connections between the chamber’s foundation, the National Chamber Foundation, and another philanthropy, the Starr Foundation, which made large grants to the chamber foundation in 2003 and 2004. During the same period, the National Chamber Foundation lent the chamber $18 million, most of it for what was described as a capital campaign.

What are the possible implicationns of the New York investigation? The Times spells it out:

Mr. Schneiderman’s investigation is the first significant one in years into the rapidly growing use of tax-exempt groups to move money into politics. The biggest such groups, including Americans for Prosperity, which is backed by the billionaire brothers Charles and David Koch, and Crossroads Grassroots Policy Strategies, which was founded by Karl Rove and other Republican strategists, are expected to spend hundreds of millions of dollars this year on issue advertisements against candidates to sway the outcome of the presidential and Congressional elections. 
But the sources of that money are largely obscured from public view by mazes of transactions between allied groups and laws that allow tax-exempt organizations — unlike candidates and “super PACs” — to shield their donors. 
Calls from Democrats and ethics watchdogs for tighter oversight of the groups’ political activities have resulted in little action by either the Federal Election Commission, which is deadlocked over the issue, or the Internal Revenue Service, which regulates charities at the federal level. But the subpoena from Mr. Schneiderman, a Democrat who made tougher campaign finance laws a centerpiece of his 2010 election campaign, suggests that he — like his predecessors Eliot Spitzer and Andrew M. Cuomo — is preparing to aggressively exploit the unusually broad regulatory powers of his office to vault onto the national stage.

Could this wind up being a case of "Eliot Spitzer's Revenge"? The former attorney general and governor of New York appeared to be on the verge of busting AIG in early 2008 when he was brought down by his own prostitution-related scandal. AIG went on to play a major role in the U.S. financial meltdown that preceeded the 2008 presidential election. Schneiderman's investigation has a strong AIG flavor. Reports The Times:

The Starr Foundation is one of the country’s largest philanthropies, with total assets of about $1.3 billion. Named after Cornelius Vander Starr, the founder of American International Group, the foundation is headed by Maurice R. Greenberg, who was AIG’s chairman until being forced out in 2005. As AIG chairman, Mr. Greenberg also served on the board of the Chamber of Commerce and was a vocal advocate of legislation limiting class action lawsuits. 
The National Chamber Foundation has not confirmed that the Starr Foundation grants paid for its loan to the chamber. But the chamber foundation’s tax returns suggest that the loan would not have been possible without the Starr grants, which totaled roughly $19 million.

The so-called "tort reform" movement has been shoved down the throats of middle-class Americans, largely with the help of AIG, the U.S. Chamber, and Karl Rove. Southern states, such as Alabama and Mississippi, have been key battlegrounds in the effort to elect corporate-friendly judges. As a result, our state courts have become grotesquely corrupt, with simple procedural and statutory law misapplied--and clear case law routinely ignored.

What kind of financial chicanery was driving that train? Perhaps Schneiderman will helps us find out.


Anonymous said...

Eric T. Schneiderman, AG, NY. He is the law in charge of investigating Financial Fraud with an Enforcement Task Force, The Residential Mortgage-Backed Securities Working Group. via fax 225.334.4707; and 120 Broadway, Floor 25, New York NY 12224-0341.

also c/o The Capitol, Albany N.Y.

The so-called "charities" in the U.S. were-are intentional money laundering, and religions always get A PASS, ah hem, the Baptist "Church" was the "best investment the Rockefeller family ever made."

Again, the American History BIBLE is found in The Wandering Who, by Gilad Atzmon. Move on to the Fritz Kraemer ON EXCELLENCE Pentagon military owned USA via the usual suspects: Rove, et al. Study the art film by Yoav Shamir and then ask the question about INSURANCE, as well as other important questions.

Georgia Guidestones and Maurice Strong gone to China to hide just like AIG.

Happy financial independence?

Anonymous said...

Actually, the FAX for the AG is 212.416.8139, the 225 area code is a # for ?, according to the AG's office AND to call, 212.416.8050

Attorney General Schneiderman according to

he appears "clean" and so did E.S. who no doubt saved his wife and daughters from a fate awaited by those that disagree, ask JFK.

Look at Wayne Madsen's new book and then ask: are we different than the "stans" whom are in a military coup, too?!

Gilad Atzmon unveils the blood sacrifice at long last in The Wandering Who.

David said...

50 years ago almost all local chambers were members of the US CChamber. I don't think that is true today. It would be interesting to know what % of local chambers belong today.

legalschnauzer said...


That's a good question. Ralph Stacy was head of a group of local chambers, mostly in small-town Alabama. Bill Canary badly wanted to have Stacy's group, with its large membership, folded into BCA. That happened, and Stacy wound up with an office in BCA headquarters, where he was found dead from a shotgun blast. I've heard from some of Stacy's friends, and they believe he had deep second thoughts about having his association become part of Canary's group. They also do not seem to think that Stacy's death was a suicide.

David said...

Two questions:

-How did Stacy get a shotgon into his BCA office unseen?

- How did he fire the shot gun? Was it with his big toe? The state medical examiner who udes come to the part of the state where I lived alwsays said it could not be done with a standard length shotgun, only one with a sawed off barrel? He same the big toe theory was just a cover for a homicide.

Given Bill Canawry's association with Karl Rove, I believe that he is capable of doing anything to accomplish his objectives

Phyllis D. James said...

The Starr Foundation was created by C.V. Starr, whose name came up a few years ago in connection to the collapsed insurance giant AIG. It had many overlapping connections with OSS and CIA in Asia up until Starr's death in 1968. Undoubtedly the foundation is still up to no good.