Monday, July 21, 2008
UAB's Spin Machine Lurches Into Action
Garrison might have been better served by leaving her clunky PR apparatus parked in the garage.
How did Garrison decide to deal with the heat she was receiving? Why, by making false and defamatory statements about the very employee her institution had wrongfully terminated.
You would think that someone with the letters "Ph.D." after her name would be smarter than that. You would think that someone with a background in nursing would have more sensitivity than that.
You would be wrong.
Garrison, of course, could not lower herself to trash me herself. So she assigned that duty to her PR hatchetman, Gary Mans.
A number of folks who had contacted UAB about my termination received canned replies late last week. Several of those folks were kind enough to share the responses with me.
Here is UAB's official reply from Gary Mans, speaking on Carol Garrison's behalf:
President Garrison asked that I respond to you. Contrary to Mr. Shuler's statements, his termination had nothing to do with politics or any conspiracy, and the university has not been contacted by any public official or representative of such about this matter. Mr. Shuler was dismissed based solely on his work performance. Because this is a personnel matter, we cannot comment further.
Gary Mans, Director
UAB Public Relations
For good measure, Mans went to the trouble of posting his reply as a comment to the Chronicle of Higher Education article about my termination. You can check out Mans' handiwork here. His comment is No. 16. The commenter at No. 17 promptly ripped Mans a new one. Excellent work by the Chronicle crowd. They don't suffer fools gladly.
Is Gary Mans careless, clueless, or spineless--or perhaps a little of all three. Is Carol Garrison in way over her head as the president of one of the top biomedical research institutions in the country? Does Carol Garrison allow herself to be pushed around by public officials of a certain political stripe? And does Carol Garrison let herself be pushed around by certain members of the University of Alabama Board of Trustees, who "manage" the UAB campus.
Let's examine the Garrison/Mans reply in some detail.
They say I was "dismissed based solely on [my] work performance."
Isn't that interesting? UAB's own employee grievance committee, which spent three-plus hours going over the details of my case, determined that I should not have been terminated at all.
As we reported here last Thursday, the grievance committee found that I was wrongfully terminated. We even presented the following written statement from Cheryl Locke, UAB's director of human resources: "The committee recommended that you be reinstated."
So Garrison/Mans say I was dismissed based solely on my work performance. A UAB grievance committee, which Garrison and Mans should be familiar with, says I should not have been terminated at all.
Bottom line? Garrison and Mans have gone out of their collective way to make a false statement that has damaged my reputation. And they have made sure it was distributed to numerous third parties. That's a serious civil wrong. A malicious civil wrong, I would say.
But that might be the least of UAB's problems. If my termination was the result of a conspiracy to commit fraud, and I will present evidence that it was, UAB personnel appear to be furthering that fraudulent scheme by use of the federal wires (sending messages via computer). That's dancing real close to federal-crime territory.
Of course, with a loyal Bushie such as Alice Martin serving as our area's U.S. attorney, no one at UAB has anything to worry about--for now. And given that Martin almost certainly played a role in getting me fired, UAB types probably are acting as her compliant compadres.
But if there is a God in heaven, Alice Martin will be out of office come early 2009. And given that she is being investigated by several federal entities, Ms. Martin might have some serious legal headaches of her own down the road.
UAB could be left with a real U.S. attorney, someone who might be interested in their actions regarding my termination--and a number of other interesting activities on the Southside over the past 10 years or so. Said U.S. attorney also might be interested in some interesting business activities involving one or two members of the University of Alabama Boad of Trustees.
Speaking of strange stuff on the Southside, here is something to chew on--straight from public records. UAB pays Gary Mans, its public-relations guru, $99,999.96 a year. The university pays his immediate superior, associate vice president Dale Turnbough, $200,000.40 a year. What does UAB pay one of its top history professors? Try $82,800. What does UAB pay one of its top English professors? Try $78,710.
Does UAB have its priorities in order or what? It pays two PR flacks a combined $300,000-plus a year. And yet highly accomplished professors of history and English, people with doctoral degrees and years of classroom and research experience, make barely half that, combined.
What does UAB get from its high-paid PR flacks? Well, we've already shown you Gary Mans' handiwork above. What about Dale Turnbough? Consider this paragraph from the Raw Story article about my firing:
When asked whether Shuler was fired for blogging, Turnbough wrote in an e-mail, "No, as I said before, that is inaccurate, but we cannot comment further on this personnel matter." (Sounds like Garrison and Mans didn't have any problem commenting further!)
How inept has UAB been in handling this situation? Gary Mans' office is on the 13th floor of the UAB Administration Building. Cheryl Locke's office is on the second floor of the same building. If you time the elevators right, you can get from Mans' office to Locke's office in under a minute. And yet, Mans could not be bothered to check with Locke before issuing a public statement regarding my firing--one that directly contradicts what Locke had already said.
And we mentioned spine earlier. If Carol Garrison insisted on making this statement regarding "work performance," wouldn't you think Mans might say something like, "You know, I don't think it's a good idea to say anything about his work performance, particularly when you consider that Dale Turnbough already has said we can't comment on a personnel matter?"
Of course, it would require some spine to say that to the president of the university. And I guess you have to pay more than $100,000 a year to get a PR guy with a spine.
So we have Gary Mans saying my termination had nothing to do with politics. And we have Dale Turnbough saying my termination had nothing to do with blogging.
Well, I have some evidence that suggests they are both wrong.
That is coming up next.
Was I Fired Because of Politics? You Make the Call
Do Dale Turnbough and Gary Mans know what they are talking about?
Well, let's just say we have some evidence that begs to differ with the UAB spin machine.
This evidence comes from Anita Bonasera, director of employee relations at UAB. Bonasera conducted the May 7 meeting at which I was placed on administrative leave (before being fired on May 19).
At the close of the May 7 meeting, Bonasera asked for my employee badge and office key, told me I was not to report to work until further notice, and that I would not be allowed to return to my desk to gather my personal belongings. You might say I now know what it is like to be treated like a criminal. (By the way, more than two months later, UAB still has a number of my personal belongings--even though I have repeatedly asked for their return.)
Since that May 7 meeting, a UAB employee grievance committee has found that I never should have been terminated. I sat through the entire grievance hearing, and saw that not one shred of documentation was presented to support my termination, the administrative leave, or any other form of discipline.
In short, UAB's own committee found that the university screwed up royally. But I'm still waiting for an apology from Bonasera for seeing to it that I was treated like a criminal. I'm also still waiting to be reinstated to the job I never should have had stolen from me--and to have my personnel file cleared of bogus written warnings that never should have been there.
So far, UAB Human Resources Director Cheryl Locke has insisted that I can only return to UAB with two written warnings in my file and if I accept a position other than the one I used to hold. I've refused those conditions for reasons I cited here, so I expect to receive written notice in the mail any day that Locke is going to uphold a termination that her own committee found was wrongful.
But let's return to the subject of Bonasera. Before making sure I was treated like a criminal, she told me that I could file a written response to the administrative leave letter from my supervisor, Pam Powell. (The same Pam Powell against whom I had a pending grievance at the time I was placed on leave. UAB policy says an employee cannot be penalized for filing a grievance. But I was fired after filing a grievance. Policy, schmolicy.)
Powell's letter was so vague, and the issues raised verbally in the meeting had been so off-the-wall, that I needed to call Bonasera to ask her several questions regarding my response.
For one thing, I wanted to ask Bonasera for an extension of time to prepare the response. One of the most baffling charges in the meeting had been that I had engaged in excessive "non-work related activity" (NWR) on my work computer. I had never heard of the term NWR while at UAB and had never seen it defined in UAB policy. Also, I had no idea who made the determination that something was or was not NWR. (Bonasera informed me that Pam Powell made that determination, the same Pam Powell against whom I had a pending grievance. How's that for objectivity?)
For some reason, I thought it might be helpful to explain the nature of my job to Bonasera, to show that what Powell was suddenly calling NWR actually was activity that was part of my job requirements (as outlined numerous times over the years by Powell herself).
I thought it might be helpful to tape record my conversation with Bonasera. After sitting through the administrative-leave meeting, with its Alice in Wonderland qualities, I wanted to make sure I had a record of the charges being leveled against me. Seeing as how UAB had not given me a written description of these charges, I thought I had better get a tape recorded version of them myself. (By the way, it is legal in Alabama to tape record a phone conversation, as long as one party knows about it.)
Following is a roughly three-minute segment of my conversation with Anita Bonasera. It leaves little doubt about what was actually behind the process that led to my termination at UAB. The key statements from Bonasera--regarding the role blogging and Don Siegelman played in the investigation of my computer usage--start at about the 1:50 mark.
You can listen to the audio here:
Audio: UAB and the Cost of Blogging About the Siegelman Case
Do UAB's high-paid PR flacks have a clue about what really happened in my case? Or are they just "expert" liars? Did my termination really have anything to do with work performance? Or was it a political "career assassination," driven by right-wingers who were uncomfortable with the truths presented on this blog?
You make the call.
Monday, September 23, 2024
Within seconds, Birmingham's bustling Five Points South turns into a scene of chaos and bloodshed as the scourge of mass gun violence spreads to a special place
![]() |
| The iconic fountain in Five Points South (AL.com) |
Birmingham, Alabama, the city where I gave birth to this blog 17 years ago, was the site Saturday night of a mass shooting that left 17 people injured and four people dead. Law-enforcement authorities say the incident appears to be a "hit," perhaps a murder-for-hire. They believe the target of the shooters was among those killed. The shooting took place in the popular Five Points South entertainment district, which is filled with bars, nightclubs, restaurants, and music venues. Witnesses said the district was bustling with activity when shots rang out Saturday night. Soon, blood could be seen pooling on sidewalks, near street corners and crosswalks, and vehicles parked nearby.
Five Points South is located just a few steps from the campus of the University of Alabama at Birmingham (UAB), where I worked for roughly 25 years before being cheated out of my job for daring to write a blog about legal and political corruption in the area, most of it with roots in Shelby County, which is well outside the Birmingham city limits.
What happened to me at UAB? I might never know the full story. But I do have evidence that at least two lawyers were displeased about my reporting and were concerned it might interfere with the haul they hoped to rake in from participation in a lawsuit that evolved from the HealthSouth Corporation accounting scandal. Both of these lawyers have enough ties to UAB and state government to get me fired for no reason -- and if they did not actually push for the firing, they almost certainly know who did.
![]() |
| The Hush Lounge (NY Times) |
Why start a blog about corruption in the Birmingham area? Well, because of a difficult neighbor named Mike McGarity (with an extensive criminal record), who moved in next door and kept trying to make our real property (our yard) his own, my wife Carol and I wound up in court trying to protect what was legally ours and to keep someone from getting hurt on our property, which likely would have caused our homeowner's insurance to skyrocket. I wrote in 2012 that I saw signs McGarity might be dangerous, and he later proved me correct by committing felony assault by hitting me in the back with a roadside sign. I refused to press charges because Shelby County deputies would not bring the case as a felony, which it clearly was under state law (see here and here).
Carol and I kept running headlong into judges who served up rulings that had nothing to do with the actual law. This started with state-court judges in Shelby County named Ron Jackson, J. Michael Joiner, and, Dan Reeves. The mainstream media largely ignored the activities of rogue judges, so I figured citizens would have no idea how their taxpayer dollars were being wasted if I didn't step forward and tell them. That is how Legal Schnauzer was born.
In 2012, a Chicago-based company called Cision, which bills itself as "a leading global provider of media relations software services and research solutions for public relations professionals" named us among the top 50 independent law blogs in North America.
We were ranked No. 37, and since we were not affiliated with any law firm, law school, media company, publishing house, business enterprise, group-blogging effort, or professional association we were one of only two truly independent blogs on the list.
The only other independent blog on the list appears to be Grits for Breakfast,
which focuses on the Texas criminal justice system and came in at No.
3. It is the work of Scott Henson, who describes himself as "a former
journalist turned opposition researcher/political consultant, public
policy researcher and blogger."
Henson has been an associate editor at Texas Observer
and has worked for the ACLU, the Sunshine Project for Police
Accountability, and the Innocence Project of Texas. He has an impressive
background, and if I am alone in his company on the Cision list . . .
well, that seems like a pretty good place to be.
Let's return to the subject of UAB and the mass shooting that turned the usually joy-filled Five Points South into a deadly setting.
As for UAB, why would the highly regarded university -- the driving engine of Birmingham's economy -- fire a veteran employee who engaged in activity that clearly was protected by the First Amendment, and I did it on my own time, with my own resources? In fact, UAB could not even settle on any offense I committed, certainly not a fireable offense. In a grievance hearing, my supervisor Pam Powell admitted she had no evidence to support her actions against me, and a UAB IT employee named Sean Maher, said he had been asked to monitor my computer use for 30 days and found I had never opened my blog at work, much less actually worked on it. No one else in our group was subjected to such surveillance, only me. Why would Powell and her cohorts repeatedly deal with my situation in violation of the UAB Employee Handbook?
UAB's public-relations spin machine was an embarrassment, tossing out claims that ran wildly contrary to the findings of their own grievance committee. Gary Mans and Dale Turnbough were the main perpetrators of this hatchet job designed to destroy my reputation.
If you get cheated out of your job, can you count on a federal judge to provide justice? Oh, no. My UAB case helped bring me into the presence of four federal judges -- William Marsh Acker Jr., Abdul Kallon, David Proctor, and Virginia Emerson Hopkins. Acker now is deceased, and two of the other three no longer are active federal judges. Acker's actions in my case were particularly grotesque. He granted summary judgment to the university without giving me a chance to conduct any discovery, which is a gross violation of both procedural and case law. (See Snook v. Trust Company of Georgia, 859 F. 2d 865 (11th Cir., 1988).) He told me in open court that he was going to cheat me repeatedly by abusing the process for a writ of mandamus, which is a form of interlocutory appeal.
Despite periods of unpleasantness, I still hold many fond memories of UAB. And most anyone who has spent time in Birmingham, has been to Five Points South-- and it's hard not to enjoy the place, partly because of its eclectic mix of establishments -- from The Original Pancake House to Golden Temple Natural Grocery and Cafe to the now-defunct (but never forgotten) Charlemagne Records.
So, what exactly happened Saturday night in Five Points South? The chaotic nature of the incident, and the lack of time that has passed, make it difficult to piece together the facts. But here is one of the best accounts we've seen, from Carol Robinson, veteran crime reporter for Al.com (formerly The Birmingham News), plus Ruth Serven Smith, and Hannah Denham:
Local and federal agents are searching for people with information about a deadly mass shooting that left four people dead and at least 17 others injured outside a Birmingham club Saturday night.
The shooting happened just after 11 p.m. in the 2000 block of Magnolia Avenue South, as people were standing in line to get into Hush, a hookah and cigar lounge.
Birmingham Police Chief Scott Thurmond said the shooting may have been a murder-for-hire and that more than 100 shell casings were collected at the scene.
Here’s what we know so far about the deadly shooting. This story will be updated as more information is available.
How can people help?
Police and Mayor Randall Woodfin are urging anyone with information to speak with officers. Businesses in the area are being urged to share surveillance video.
You can submit information to police here. You can also call investigators at 205-254-1764 or Crime Stoppers at 205-254-7777.
Who was killed?
Sunday evening, police identified three of the four people killed as Antria Holloman, 21, Tahj Booker, 27, and Carlos McCain, 27. A fourth person died at the hospital.
Who was injured?
Police estimate that 17 people were hurt in the shooting and ensuing chaos.
Gabriel Eslami, 24, of Trussville, was among the many injured.
“It’s just gun smoke and peoples’ bodies laid out on the pavement,’’ he said. “Physically, it’s hard to walk, but by the Grace of God, it didn’t hit anything major.”
![]() | ||
| Flowers mark the shooting scene (WVTM) |
University of Alabama at Birmingham spokesperson Alicia Rohan said on Sunday evening that UAB Hospital has treated 12 victims, total.
“This included one deceased victim brought to UAB Hospital from the scene, per the Birmingham Police Department,” she said. “We are currently treating 4 victims with conditions ranging from good to critical.”
How did the shooting occur?
Multiple shooters pulled up in a car, Thurmond said, got out and fired shots and then drove away.
The targeted victim in the murder-for-hire was likely found at the scene by the shooters. “Wherever that (targeted) person was is where it was going to take place,” Thurmond said.
Who are suspects in the shooting?
As of Sunday morning, police have not identified the suspects or people of interest.
On Sunday night, three people were shot in the South East Lake community, specifically the 700 block of 81st Place South. A man injured in that shooting died.
“One of our personnel received intel that this may be related (to the Five Points South shootings),’’ said Officer Truman Fitzgerald. “So anytime we have a community member willing to step up and give information, we’re going to investigate that the best we can.”
Was the Hush Lounge involved?
Ryan Pryor, who opened Hush in 2019 and retired after 20 years as a Birmingham police officer in March, was at his club when shots rang out.
“I would like to stress that this had nothing to do with Hush itself. My heart goes out to the families, and I stand with Birmingham on correcting this violence. This gun violence has to stop,” Pryor said.
On Sunday morning, Pryor was preparing to reopen the business.“We need to try to get back to some kind of normalcy,” he said.
Hush, at 2012 Magnolia Ave., is a speakeasy-style lounge located in the underground space at Pickwick Place retail center. The club often features bottle service, parties, DJs and recently celebrated its fifth-year anniversary in June.
Birmingham Mayor Randall Woodfin asked Sunday morning for help from state officials to regulate conversion devices that turn guns into automatic weapons.
“Converting
a semi-automatic weapon into a fully automatic weapon that discharges
all bullets within seconds doesn’t belong on our domestic streets,”
Woodfin said in a Facebook post
Sunday morning. “This shouldn’t be up for debate. This morning, too
many families have to pick up the pieces of an unfair new normal that
doesn’t include their love one.”
More hush lounge shooting
- Birmingham shooting that kills 1, injures 2 possibly linked to 5 Points South mass homicide
- 3 of 4 victims killed in Birmingham mass shooting identified; 17 others wounded
- ‘There was blood everywhere’: Birmingham mass shooting survivor says he is ‘blessed beyond blessed’
- Birmingham could break a tragic 91-year-old record after multiple mass shootings
- Retired cop who owns Hush Lounge: ‘Gun violence has to stop’ after Birmingham mass shooting ‘pandemonium’

Police mark off the shooting scene (AL.com)


