Thursday, May 16, 2019

Alabama's "fetal heartbeat" bill is built on a mountain of deceitful language and medical ignorance, but mostly white, male lawmakers don't seem to care


Ultrasound of fetal cardiac activity at 6 weeks and 1 day.

The Alabama Senate on Tuesday approved a bill that effectively would outlaw all abortions in the state, with the votes of 25 white, male (Republican) senators leading the way. That speaks to rank hypocrisy that long has held center stage in the "pro life" movement. But more concerning should be the stupidity and dishonesty involved in the process. Gov. Kay Ivey signed the bill into law yesterday.

A group of prominent gynecologists has said "fetal heartbeat" bills, which tend to ban abortions after six weeks, often are based on medical and biological ignorance and fraudulent use of the English language. Dr. Jen Gunter, a Canadian gynecologist who writes the influential blog drjengunter.com has been pointing this out for years. Consider this 2016 post titled "Dear Press, stop calling them “heartbeat” bills and call them “fetal pole cardiac activity” bills": Warning: Dr. Gunter has a tendency to use blunt, foul language at times.)

Ohio is the latest state to attempt to pass a medically illiterate abortion “heartbeat” bill.

It’s bad enough that these bills exist, but the press needs to do a better job of calling them what they are. If politicians want to play doctor they should be using medical terms. If they refuse to use the correct terminology, the press should correct them. People who vote for the assholes who write these shit shows know them as “heartbeat bills” not because they follow them as they groan through committee, but because that is how they read or hear about them in the news. The politicians know exactly what they are doing as a “heartbeat” bills is a way of making a 4 mm thickening next to a yolk sac seem like it is almost ready to walk.
Anti-choice embryo
Fetal cardiac activity can be detected as early at six weeks from the last menstrual period. The ultrasound [above] shows an image at 6 weeks and 1 day. (See image at the top of this post.)

The fetal pole is between the two markers and is a thickening at the end of the yolk sac (the yolk sac is the circular blob) and contains the earliest ultrasound evidence of cardiac activity. I know some have wondered why not use the term embryo, but as it’s the fetal pole that is being measured I think the term “fetal” is technically fine.
However, when most people think of a heartbeat they don’t think of a 4.3 mm thickening next to a blob they think of something like this. (See image, above right.)

The image (above, right) is an anti-choice version of an embryo, obviously not a faithful representation of size or appearance. If you want a real picture for comparison, check out this link. (See image at the end of this post.)

Is the "pro life" movement designed to deceive? Absolutely, and Dr. Gunter has seen it firsthand:

I expect nothing less than a campaign of misinformation from the misogynistic degenerates who hold office in these places. I worked in Kansas for many years and after a restrictive law passed I found myself in a three-way phone call with the hospital attorney and the politician playing doctor who tacked on the abortion rider to the bill that turned the governance of Kansas University Medical Center (KUMC) to a private authority. Yes, that’s right the State legislature in Kansas held the hospital’s financial future hostage over abortion and the Dean and the University caved. The politician who added the abortion rider to the bill was simply shocked that an abortion could actually be needed for health reasons. I mean he was gobsmacked. He believed the lie hook, line, and sinker that pregnancy never maims or kills. He was also somewhat shocked that the hospital attorney had tracked him down at night and that he had to explain what he meant by “the life of the mother being in danger” to a doctor. Dear Reader, the hospital attorney was worried we would be sued if this non-doctor didn’t think the woman was sick enough so I had to call and explain modern OB/GYN to Chance the gardener.

After some silence and muttering he said something like, Oh my, just do your doctoring of course. I am sure that even before the receiver hit the cradle the drop of truth that I had forced him to drink was rapidly diluted by the poison he’d been supping since birth and that woman and every single one like her dropped like chaff from his narrow little mind.

If Dr. Gunter sounds disgusted with the "fetal heartbeat" crowd, it's probably because she knows what she is talking about -- and they don't:

No one passing these laws gives a shit about the medicine or the science or the statistics. Really, they don’t. If they did, these laws wouldn’t exist and there would be laws providing free long-acting reversible contraception because that’s actually what works. I really believe the assholes in Ohio who voted for the fetal pole cardiac activity bill truly believe that the more than 21,000 women in Ohio who get abortions each year are just doing so because the greedy doctors who run the abortion spa at the mall have frequent BOGOs on pleasure abortions and if these little women just had a firmer hand from the patriarchy they would see the error of their ways. As pregnant women needing abortions won’t be picketing their offices they will take the silence as tactic approval, but who has time to picket and march when it’s tic toc. Women will be panicked making calls to find an out-of-state clinic and many will be raising money. Anyway, even if you do have the cash on hand, do you want your face in the paper so your rapist can see you got pregnant? Maybe you don’t want your parents to know, not because your are a teen, but because you are a grown-ass woman and it’s no one else’s fucking business what you do with your body?

In short, bills like the one in Alabama are based on "fetal heartbeats" that don't exist. That's because there is no heart at six weeks, and in medical terms, it isn't yet a fetus; it's an embryo. Writes Dr. Gunter:

While the press doesn’t write bills or pass laws they do pass on information or in this case subtle misinformation. Using “heartbeat” anywhere in a piece, but especially in the headline, even in quotations is not appropriate. It’s no different from allowing a neo Nazi to self identify as alt-right.

The earliest cardiac activity is seen in a fetal pole and using any other term means that you are lock step with a campaign of misinformation and it’s wrong.

The politicians who write these bills are dealing in misinformation and the press should refuse to play the game.




15 comments:

Anonymous said...

Hell, even Pat Robertson said the Alabama law goes too far. It takes some effort to turn Pat Robertson's stomach.

Anonymous said...

So, Alabama's white, male legislators and its lesbian, spinster guv ("Cowgirl Kay") made this happen.

Anonymous said...

By now, Missouri has knocked Alabama off of the headlines. I hope all of this spurs voters forward to show up at the polls and vote!!! Particularly white suburban women who voted for Trump for "money reasons", ignoring all of his other crazy s@#t. Karma.

legalschnauzer said...

@11:43 --

Thanks for the update. As I like to say, "Missouri is just Alabama with snowballs."

legalschnauzer said...

Here is article about Missouri bill. Senate has passed it and sounds like Gov. Mike Parson (yes, a while, male GOPer) plans to sign by end of week.

Anonymous said...

How would Eric Greitens have handled this if he were still governor of Missouri? He clearly was a "pro life" and "pro family" guy -- when he wasn't trying to bang his hair stylist.

Anonymous said...

LS -- Your posts have educated me more on abortion than anything I've read in a long time. Many thanks.

Anonymous said...

Pro lifers have been messing with the language forever, probably starting with "unborn child." A child, by definition, is born -- or that's the way it used to be. The fundies are constantly coining new and deceptive phrases to fit their needs.

Anonymous said...

A spot-on column from Joey Kennedy of APR:


https://www.alreporter.com/2019/05/16/opinion-legislature-to-women-go-to-hell/

Robby Scott Hill said...

Money money money money, money [Repeat: x 6]
Some people got to have it
Some people really need it
Listen to me why'all, do things, do things, do bad things with it
You want to do things, do things, do things, good things with it
Talk about cash money, money
Talk about cash money- dollar bills, why'all
For the love of money
People will steal from their mother
For the love of money
People will rob their own brother
For the love of money
People can't even walk the street
Because they never know who in the world they're gonna beat
For that lean, mean, mean green
Almighty dollar, money
For the love of money
People will lie, Lord, they will cheat
For the love of money
People don't care who they hurt or beat
For the love of money
A woman will sell her precious body
For a small piece of paper it carries a lot of weight
Call it lean, mean, mean green
Almighty dollar
I know money is the root of all evil
Do funny things to some people
Give me a nickel, brother can you spare a dime
Money can drive some people out of their minds
Got to have it, I really need it
How many things have I heard you say
Some people really need it
How many things have I heard you say
Got to have it, I really need it
How many things have I heard you say
Lay down, lay down, a woman will lay down
For the love of money
All for the love of money
Don't let, don't let, don't let money rule you
For the love of money
Money can change people sometimes
Don't let, don't let, don't let money fool you
Money can fool people sometimes
People! Don't let money, don't let money change you,
It will keep on changing, changing up your mind

Anonymous said...

Thank you for this insightful article. The contrast between the two pictures is impacting

Anonymous said...

"What happens during week 5 - 6?...A very basic beating heart and circulatory system develop."

That's from Planned Parenthood's own web page located here:

https://www.plannedparenthood.org/learn/pregnancy/pregnancy-month-by-month/what-happens-second-month-pregnancy

legalschnauzer said...

@1:54 --

I would suggest you refer to a couple of other places in this PP document. Just above "What happens in weeks 5 and 6" you will find this sentence regarding week 6: "This is when all the major internal organs start developing." In other words, the organs are developing, but they aren't fully formed. There is no heart, as Dr. Gunter states in my post.

If you scroll to "What happens in weeks 7 and 8," you will see these words: "The heart has formed." Just as Dr. Gunter states in my post, there is no heart at week 6. That doesn't form until week 7-8.

Everything in my post is accurate, and I would say PP did a poor job of preparing this doc. It should have said an "embryonic cardiac pole develops," which is factual, but I assume they got lazy and used the term ""basic beating heart," thinking people can understand that better.

Anonymous said...

At 4 weeks there are four distinct chambers of the heart. At 8 weeks fully developed. There's no such scientific term as "fetal pole activity". That's just a euphemism for heartbeat. But even if you reject the earlier activity there is no doubt that there is a "heartbeat" at 8 weeks.

legalschnauzer said...

And we're to believe you over Dr. Jen Gunter, a veteran OB/GYN? Why don't you share your name, locations/affiliations, and credentials?