Showing posts sorted by date for query Ali Alexander. Sort by relevance Show all posts
Showing posts sorted by date for query Ali Alexander. Sort by relevance Show all posts

Wednesday, September 16, 2026

From a criminal record for extortion and battery to dark ties to sports betting and a national lottery in Russia, Umar Kremlev comes from a sketchy world -- one Donald Trump Jr. might someday wish he hadn't entered

Donald Trump Jr. and Bettina Anderson dance at their wedding (Laura Gordon/Hello!)


According to published reports, Donald Trump Jr. has a net worth of roughly $300 million. So why did he need a Russian oligarch, one with direct ties to Vladimir Putin, to help pay for his wedding in late May of this year? That is one of many questions raised by reporting from ProPublica under the headline "Donald Trump Jr.'s Bahamas wedding was secretly bankrolled by Russian oligarch close to Putin. 

A subhead adds important details: "The oligarch, Umar Kremlev, spent hundreds of thousands on expenses like renting out a private island. He appears to have met Trump Jr. only recently, but he attended the intimate wedding with a large group of other Russian guests. A reporting team of Justin Elliott, Brett Murphy, Joshua Kaplan, and Alex Mierjeski writes:

On May 24, Donald Trump Jr. was celebrating in the Bahamas, as scantily clad dancers in stilettos and sailor caps performed for him and his guests. It was the last night of his wedding, a lavish, three-day party held across a pair of ultra-exclusive private islands. A five-tier funfetti cake had been airlifted in from Florida, and helicopters and seaplanes descended on the islands before guests settled into their oceanfront villas. That night on the beach, Trump Jr. lifted his bride into the air while fireworks launched from a barge over the sea.

“It was everything we dreamed of and more,” his wife later wrote on Instagram.

Kremlev footed the bill for hundreds of thousands of dollars of wedding expenses, according to records reviewed by ProPublica and interviews with three people familiar with the event. The oligarch paid to rent out one of the private islands, where a reception was held and where guests slept. He also covered other big-ticket items, like the fireworks show, and his team helped plan the event. Kremlev is the head of the International Boxing Association (IBA), a scandal-plagued sports group that has been financed by the Russian state-owned energy giant Gazprom. The wedding payments came from an IBA-affiliated entity in Dubai that the boxing association uses for financial transactions. 

Trump Jr. has a fair amount of experience with weddings and the like. He and his first wife, Vanessa Trump, were married from 2005 to 2018 and share five children together. His second wife now is Bettina Anderson, a Palm Beach socialite and model. In between the two marriages, Trump Jr. was engaged to former Fox News host Kimberly Guilfoyle between 2020 and 2024, but they never married. One might think that Trump Jr. would prefer to make this wedding a low-key affair. But we are talking about the Trump family here, so bigger likely will always be seen as better -- especially when someone else is paying for it. Actually, in terms of attendees, it was low key, as the ProPublica team writes:

The guest list numbered around 50. It included Trump Jr.’s brother-in-law Jared Kushner, Eric Trump — and Kremlev, an imposing man with a shaved head who speaks limited English. The oligarch was part of a large group whose presence puzzled other attendees. They sometimes stood off by themselves, speaking Russian.

“It was really small, like, just really close friends,” Trump Jr. later said on his podcast. “Tried to keep it really tight. And it was just awesome.” 

As to our question at the top of this post. Trump Jr. obviously did not need Umar Kremlev, or anyone else, to help pay for his wedding. So, why did it happen?  

The relationship between giver and receiver seems tenuous, and perhaps that is why some national-security experts have expressed reservations about the arrangement, according to the ProPublica team:

Kremlev’s previously unreported relationship with Trump Jr. represents an extraordinary development: a member of Putin’s circle financially supporting the president’s son and gaining intimate access to the Trump family. For a decade, Putin’s government, regarded as a chief adversary of the U.S., has been accused of efforts to influence American elections. Attempts by Russia to make inroads with the Trumps before the 2016 election exploded into controversy that dogged much of the president’s first term.

National security experts expressed alarm at Trump Jr. accepting the oligarch’s largesse, saying it raised an urgent question: What motivated Kremlev to spend a fortune cultivating the connection? 

“If I’m paying for your wedding, at some point, you’re going to owe me something,” said Frank Montoya Jr., a retired career FBI official who held senior counterintelligence roles. Oligarchs like Kremlev often act in coordination with the Russian government. While it’s unclear if that happened here, Trump Jr. put himself in a precarious position, Montoya said. “This should be unthinkable for the son of the president. End of story.”

Montoya's comment strikes at the heart of the matter because it raises the issue of a possible quid pro quo (a "something for something" deal). Ironically, that was a major issue in the prosecution of former Alabama Governor Don Siegelman, which we covered extensively from roughly 2004 to 2012. That's because my wife Carol and I lived in Alabama at the time, and that is where the Legal Schnauzer blog was born in June 2007.

To be sure, there are differences between the Siegelman case and the Kremlev-Trump Jr. gift. The Siegelman matter was governed largely by a landmark case styled McCormick vs. United States 500 U.S. 257 (1991), which held that a conviction of an elected official under the Hobbs Act requires proof of an explicit quid pro quo. In short, McCormick defines the difference between a bribe and a lawful contribution in the context of a political campaign.

Trump Jr. never has held public office or been a candidate in a political campaign? He has served on his father's presidential transition team and as a fundraiser for conservative candidates. But that likely would not bring him  under the campaign-contribution guidelines of McCormick.

Still, should Trump Jr. have declined the gift from Kremlev? Like Montoya, my answer is yes, simply because it looks bad to have a benefactor who is tied to Putin, one of the most notorious and murderous fascists in history. And someone in authority -- such as the president of the United States -- should have been smart enough to make sure his son steered clear of Putin's pal.

For one thing, the gift likely gives Democrats a potent political weapon they will be happy to use in future elections. Plus, it's not hard to imagine a scenario where the gift comes back to bite the Trump family. Let's say Democrats take back the House and Senate in 2026, or the White House plus Congress and the judiciary in 2028. What if Dems conduct investigations that show Kremlev consulted Trump Sr. about the gift, and the president was all for it, even suggesting it be done in the form of a wedding gift. Imagine that evidence showed Trump Sr. used a portion of the Kremlev funds for a future campaign of his own or for those of other Republicans. Would that bring him under McCormick and cause massive headaches for the GOP, up and down the ballot? In my view, the answer is yes. Here is more from the ProPublica report:

Holden Triplett, who served as Trump’s counterintelligence director on the National Security Council during his first term, said Russian intelligence frequently seeks to build ties with U.S. government officials and their family members. “Money is a tried-and-true method to gain access,” said Triplett, who also worked for the FBI in Moscow.

In the days leading up to Trump Jr.’s wedding, Kremlev was in China as part of the delegation accompanying Putin, according to Chinese state media. The month before, Putin had bestowed him with a state honor, the Order of Friendship. The Ukrainian government has imposed sanctions on Kremlev personally, citing his closeness to Putin and Russian security services. 

It’s not clear why Kremlev helped pay for Trump Jr.’s wedding. The men appear to have met only recently. Public reporting suggests Trump Jr. could have afforded it himself, with Forbes recently estimating his net worth at roughly $300 million. 

In perhaps a first for the Trump family, a spokesperson for Trump Jr. seemed to be up front when hit with questions about the Kremlev gift. A spokesperson for Eric Trump, meanwhile, seemed desperate to get off the phone. Kremlev's press office gave a response, but seemed eager to distance him from political matters:

In response to detailed questions, a spokesperson for Trump Jr. did not dispute the wedding payments from Kremlev. “Umar is a personal friend of Don,” he said. The spokesman said that Kremlev is “not someone he has a business relationship with” and that the men met through a mutual friend in the hunting world and bonded over their love of boxing and the outdoors. 

A spokesperson for Trump Jr.’s brother, Eric, said of Kremlev: “Eric has absolutely no clue who this person is, nor has he ever heard his name.” 

In a statement, Kremlev’s press office said, “Mr. Kremlev and Mr. Trump Jr have a friendly relationship” and they first met “a couple of years ago.” The press office described Kremlev as a businessman and philanthropist, adding, “Mr. Kremlev has never discussed political matters with any of his American friends and acquaintances,” including Trump Jr. They said the boxing organization itself did not incur expenses for the wedding but did not comment on the payments from the Dubai entity. The press office also said that when Putin and Kremlev were in China recently, Kremlev was not part of Putin’s “official delegation.”

Kushner, who has been helping lead the U.S. government’s negotiations with Russia over Ukraine, did not respond to requests for comment. The White House and the Russian government did not respond either.

Trump Jr. has become a popular figure in conservative circles, and he seems likely to play a future role in politics. Could it be as a candidate, even for president? That does not seem to be out of the question. Early polling shows J.D. Vance at No. 1 and Marco Rubio No. 2 among GOP voters. Some conservative strategists see Trump Jr. as a candidate who might best represent the MAGA base. A recent Newsweek poll shows Trump Jr. capturing around 19 percent in a hypothetical Republican primary, placing him in the top tier of potential contenders. 

Movement since July shows Vance falling from 35 to 32 percent, and Rubio declining from 15 to 12 percent -- with Trump Jr. rising from 16 to 19 percent. That suggests Trump Jr. might be developing momentum. The ProPublica team reports:

The revelations come as Trump Jr. has emerged as a political power center in his own right. Beloved by the MAGA base, he reportedly played an active role in vetting White House cabinet picks for Trump’s second term and was dubbed his father’s “most essential political adviser” by The Wall Street Journal. “I certainly don’t think I’d be sitting here as the VP nominee without Don’s help,” Vice President JD Vance told the outlet in late 2024.

This account is based on records and interviews with dozens of current and former IBA officials and contractors, wedding attendees and other people in Trump Jr.’s and Kremlev’s circles.

As for the wedding itself, Kremlev apparently spared no expense:

Trump Jr. exchanged vows with socialite Bettina Anderson on a private island that was featured in Pirates of the Caribbean and the 2006 James Bond movie Casino Royale. They had their first dance on a second private island nearby that can rent for around $100,000 a night, paid for by Kremlev. The company that put on the fireworks display charges around $70,000 for such shows. (Kremlev did not attend the ceremony itself, which was held on the first day and had just 18 guests, Trump Jr.’s spokesperson said.)

The atmosphere was "Monte Carlo meets frat party" — helicopters in and out, a beachside DJ set, beer pong tournaments. One day, the men went spearfishing. Artisans at the London fashion house Safiyaa spent 150 hours embroidering Anderson’s bespoke silk reception outfit. The president’s son had undergone treatment to better define his jawline for the occasion.

Some longtime friends of Trump Jr. told associates they were disappointed not to be invited, though a few of his closest business partners — executives at the Trump family crypto company, World Liberty Financial, and the venture capital firm 1789 Capital — did make the cut. President Trump himself skipped it. (“He’d like me to go, but it’s going to be just a small, little private affair,” the president told reporters beforehand. “I said, you know, this is not good timing for me.”) But many of the guests were immediate family of the bride and groom.

That made the large contingent of Russians all the more conspicuous. “What are they doing here?” one person recalled thinking. At least one of the Russian guests had been with Kremlev on his China trip: Alexander Lagutin, a businessperson who has served in senior roles at a Russian defense contractor and a state-backed energy company. Kremlev’s right hand at the IBA, Elena Sobol, attended the wedding too. 

Since the wedding, the Trumps have released scores of photos and videos of the festivities. While they show many of the guests, the Russians have been absent from all of them. (The top of Kremlev’s head is visible in the back of one group photo posted on Instagram by a friend of the bride.) After the party was over, on his “Triggered” podcast, Trump Jr. emphasized the event’s privacy: “The people that were there — if you’re on that list, you weren’t talking.”

At this point, a prime question: Who is this guy from Russia, and why was he willing to pay such big dough for the wedding of a guy he had not known for long? We do know this much, thanks to ProPublica's reporting: Umar Kremlev's history is not pristine:

In 2009, Umar Kremlev did not yet exist.

He was in his late 20s, with a criminal record for extortion and battery, still going by his birth name, Umar Lutfulloyev, according to the Russian independent news outlet Proekt. But he was about to rapidly ascend in Russia to a position of wealth and influence, with the help of a powerful friend. (“Mr. Kremlev has a completely clean legal record,” his press office said, sounding a lot like Karoline Leavitt.)

In 2010, he changed his name to Kremlev. He soon joined a Russian government-backed biker gang called the Night Wolves, eventually taking a leadership role, according to news reports. That is what first brought him close to Alexei Rubezhnoi, who now leads Putin’s presidential security service, Proekt reported. In 2017, Kremlev took over the Russian Boxing Federation, after Rubezhnoi personally intervened to put him at the helm (Proekt). 

In 2020, Kremlev became president of the IBA. The association was something akin to FIFA but for boxing and had long overseen the sport in the Olympics. But it had been beset by corruption allegations and was on the brink of insolvency. Kremlev brought money to the table from Gazprom, the state-owned company that operates as an arm of Putin’s government. Gazprom publicly became the IBA’s financial backer, filling its coffers with tens of millions of dollars.

Kremlev is not just a guy with big bucks and an interest in boxing and biking. He also has a clear ideology. He has been tied to the alleged kidnapping of Ukrainian children and relocating them to Russia, the ProPublica team reports:

Former high-level IBA officials said Kremlev had a clear political agenda. “Umar is guided by Putin. It was using the sport for soft political power,” a former IBA board member told ProPublica. “It’s geopolitics. That it’s boxing is just happenstance.” Kremlev, 43, is also heavily involved in an organization called Healthy Fatherland, run by his 23-year-old wife’s twin sister. The group — which promotes healthy eating and youth sports — is under Ukrainian sanctions for its alleged role in a program of abducting Ukrainian children from occupied territories and relocating them under the guise of “rehabilitation.” (Healthy Fatherland did not respond to a request for comment.)

Kremlev’s cozy relationship with the government has made him rich. Putin used the levers of the state to make Kremlev a dominant player in the Russian sports betting industry, according to Proekt, and one of his companies was chosen to operate the national lottery. After Putin nationalized Russia’s largest car dealership company in 2023, Kremlev became the owner of that too.

He now flaunts that wealth through his boisterous public persona. In one video Kremlev posted on social media, he surprises a young mother by giving her a free car. In another, he criticizes his young female aide’s outfit as not feminine enough and makes her change. He shadowboxes with ostriches and brings in celebrities like Rick Ross and Naomi Campbell for IBA events; he praises Stalin and rides private jets.

The invasion of Ukraine ushered in a period of challenges for Kremkev, who was especially worried about possibly facing U.S. sanctions. He has made adjustments to a number of his operations, both on the business side and in the sporting arena. It's unclear, however, if he is out of the woods:

Following the Russian invasion of Ukraine in 2022, the U.S. began to indict Russian oligarchs and seize yachts and other assets. Kremlev repeatedly told associates he was worried about being targeted by a U.S. government probe, according to a person close to IBA leadership. “He was very afraid of American sanctions,” the person added. (Kremlev does not appear on public U.S. sanction lists.)

With the business environment in Europe growing more hostile to Russia, Kremlev moved much of the IBA’s operations from Switzerland to the United Arab Emirates. A new Dubai entity, IB Challenger, would later pay wedding expenses for Trump Jr. The current sources of the IBA’s funds are murky, and, in recent years, top executives have given conflicting accounts of the status of its relationship with Gazprom. (Kremlev’s press office told ProPublica the IBA’s sponsorship contract with Gazprom “expired long ago.”) People close to the organization said they understood that its money still comes from Russia. 

In 2023, the International Olympic Committee stripped Kremlev’s IBA of its role organizing Olympic boxing. It has cited a host of governance issues and the group’s refusal to “transparently explain the sources of its financing or to explain its full financial dependency, at the time, on a single state-owned company.” 

It was a major setback that deprived the IBA of a key source of its international influence. Kremlev has raged against the Olympic committee ever since and has said that his IBA predecessor, who he blames for the problems, “must be shot.” 

Where did Kremlev turn in his moment of peril? Take a guess:

Kremlev saw a potential ally in President Trump. After Trump’s second inauguration, in January 2025, Kremlev sent an open letter to the president asking him to look into the Olympic committee’s actions in advance of the 2028 Los Angeles Games. “We look forward with great optimism to the possibility of working together to make the Olympic movement great again,” he wrote. 

In September 2025, the IBA brought in Trump Jr. for a panel discussion in Istanbul about boxing. With his then-girlfriend, Anderson, sitting offstage, he criticized transgender women competing in women’s sports and reminisced about watching Saturday night fights as a child. Trump Jr. shared the stage with Kremlev, the boxer Manny Pacquiao and Muhammad Ali’s daughter Rasheda. (Trump Jr.’s spokesperson said he was not paid for the appearance and was already in Turkey for an unrelated event.) 

The more you learn about Kremlev, the sketchier he sounds. And it's hard not to think that Trump Jr. might someday regret getting involved with the Russian. If Trump Jr. does wind up running for office, opponents likely will claim the whole wedding episode raises questions about his judgment, turning a seemingly positive event into a negative. It might not help that Kremlev is trying to raise his profile in the United States: The ProPublica team writes:

The president’s son had reason to be attuned to the sensitivity of cozying up with a Putin associate, especially while his father navigates the Russia-Ukraine war. Trump Jr.’s June 2016 meeting with a Russian attorney in Trump Tower became a major focus of the Robert Mueller investigation.

The Trump Tower meeting was arranged after an email offering Trump Jr. damaging information about Hillary Clinton as “part of Russia and its government’s support for Mr. Trump.” Trump Jr. famously responded, “If it’s what you say, I love it, especially later in the summer.” Trump Jr. later dismissed the matter as a “witch hunt,” and the Mueller report concluded that there was not enough evidence to convict him of a crime.

Recently, Kremlev has been working to expand into the U.S. market. In July, his group hosted a bare-knuckle boxing event in Miami, a chance to showcase a particularly bloody form of the sport in which contenders fight without gloves. But the debut was overshadowed when manosphere influencer Andrew Tate, who the IBA had brought in to host, was arrested by U.S. Marshals outside the arena. (Tate is facing rape and sex-trafficking charges in the United Kingdom, which he has denied.) 

Much about Kremlev’s relationship with Trump Jr., and where it is headed, remains unknown. In a press release after the Istanbul panel, the IBA hinted there was more to come. 

“President Kremlev and Donald Trump Jr made it clear – this alliance will not remain symbolic,” the press release read. “More joint initiatives will follow.” 

Here is the latest information from ProPublica:

Update, Sept. 14, 2026: After the story was published, Donald Trump Jr. and Bettina Trump confirmed Umar Kremlev’s role: “Our dear friend Umar very generously hosted two incredible nights of celebrations for us,” they said in a statement published on Bettina’s Instagram account.  

“It was an extraordinarily generous wedding gift from a friend, and something for which we were and remain incredibly grateful,” they added.

“It’s unfortunate that something so personal and happy can be recast as something political or sinister simply because of who someone is or where they come from,” they wrote. “Friendship doesn’t require a political motive.” 

They also drew a distinction between the ceremony held on May 22, which was just family, and the rest of the wedding weekend.

Tuesday, June 10, 2025

Trump's call to the National Guard and Marines in L.A. makes him look like a "tough guy," but the law is clear: The president is operating on shaky legal ground

Protesters express their sentiments (Orange County Register)
 

Donald Trump long has been known as a political street fighter, who will engage in feuds of all varieties -- with foes, former friends and allies, enemies (both real and imagined), even family members (except, of course, Ivanka). As of yesterday, Trump is engaged in a real street fight, and he seems to enjoy fanning the flames. It gives Trump an opportunity to play "tough guy," and Lord knows, Trump loves being portrayed as a tough guy -- no matter how many people are injured or killed in the process.

The New York Times (NYT) has the latest story under the headline "What to Know About the Immigration Protests in Los Angeles; Demonstrations against the Trump administration’s immigration crackdown have been largely peaceful, but tensions flared after President Trump ordered National Guard troops to deploy to the city"

The Times' story is the most disturbing account of American life in the age of Trump since the violence and carnage at the U.S. Capitol on Jan. 6, 2021, which was launched in part by the actions of Alabama-connected extremist Ali (Akbar) Alexander, who has been the subject of more than 30 posts here at Legal Schnauzer -- including posts about an investigation of Alexander in Johnstown, CO, for "solicitation of a minor." That grew from a police report in which Alexander is alleged to have sought "d--k pics" from teen boys. Two of the alleged victims reportedly were ages 15 and 17 at the time. This is the kind of person with whom Trump associates, and we will have more on that in upcoming posts. Not only is Trump a poor judge of people, but he has great difficulty following the law. Maybe that is why he is America's first convicted felon/adjudicated rapist/confessed sexual abuser president.

Trump's poor judgment is on display right now in Los Angeles, where he called out the National Guard and Marines to deal with protests over his own immigration policies, which trample the law and any notion of due process. The protests have been widely described in news accounts as peaceful. Trump surely will point to arrests as a sign that protesters were unruly. But he is the one committing major violations of law, as we will show in a moment. 

Californians have not taken kindly to Trump's aggressive actions, largely bypassing the state's leaders, according to The Times:

As Los Angeles braced for more confrontations between law enforcement and demonstrators, the United States Northern Command said on Monday that the Trump administration was deploying a battalion of 700 Marines to the city to protect federal property and personnel.

The Marines were set to join hundreds of members of the California National Guard who deployed to Los Angeles on Sunday. The Guard troops were called in by President Trump, against the wishes of Gov. Gavin Newsom, after days of clashes over the weekend between the authorities and demonstrators protesting the Trump administration’s crackdown on immigration.

California’s Democratic leaders have condemned Mr. Trump’s moves. Mr. Newsom said that the order to deploy the National Guard was “purposefully inflammatory” and called for it to be rescinded. On Monday afternoon, he said the order to send hundreds of Marines to California was “a provocation, not just an escalation.”

The state attorney general, Rob Bonta, said California would file a lawsuit against the Trump administration over its move to take control of the state’s National Guard and deploy troops to Los Angeles to protect immigration enforcement agents.

The protests have been largely peaceful but have flared up in pockets of downtown Los Angeles and in nearby suburbs, as well as in San Francisco.

Protests broke out on Friday when federal agents searched the city’s garment district for workers whom they suspected of being undocumented immigrants, as part of the Trump administration’s new focus on raiding workplaces. They were met with protesters, who chanted and threw eggs before being dispersed by law enforcement with pepper spray and nonlethal bullets.

Demonstrations continued Saturday, both downtown and in the mostly Latino and working-class suburb of Paramount, about 15 miles to the south. Law enforcement officers made arrests and in some cases used crowd-control munitions, tear gas and flash-bang grenades against the protesters.

Mr. Trump signed a memo on Saturday ordering 2,000 National Guard members to deploy to Los Angeles to protect federal officers conducting immigration operations, despite the objections of Mr. Newsom and Mayor Karen Bass of Los Angeles.

On Sunday, nearly 300 members of the California National Guard took positions in the city. Demonstrations on Sunday afternoon near a downtown detention center were largely peaceful, but some protesters fired fireworks at police officers under a bridge on the nearby U.S. 101 freeway. Several driverless Waymo cars were set on fire in downtown Los Angeles.

The protests were “getting increasingly worse and more violent,” Chief McDonnell of the L.A.P.D. said on Sunday, blaming the violence on “anarchists” and “people who do this all the time,” not people protesting immigration raids.

More than 150 people have been arrested in Los Angeles since Friday, officials said. About 150 more were arrested in San Francisco, where demonstrators and police officers fought on a downtown street on Sunday night.

Did Trump act lawfully by calling in the National Guard and Marines? That question appears to be unsettled, although governors generally control such deployments in their states. That did not happen in this case, raising questions if Trump acted beyond his authority, perhaps recklessly. From The Times:

The National Guard is the only branch of the military that can be deployed both by state governors and by the president. Governors almost always control deployment in their states.

The Guard operates similarly to the Army’s reserve force. Most of its members do not serve full time. They generally hold civilian jobs and attend regular training sessions, and are called into active service only when needed. The Guard is most often called upon during extreme weather events like hurricanes, floods and wildfires.

Before Mr. Trump’s move, the last time a president activated a state’s National Guard troops for such a purpose without being asked to do so by the state’s governor was in 1965, according to Elizabeth Goitein, senior director of the Liberty and National Security Program at the Brennan Center for Justice, an independent law and policy organization.

On that occasion, she said, President Lyndon B. Johnson used troops to protect civil rights demonstrators in Alabama.

Signs point to the possibility that Trump is making creative use of language in an effort to justify his actions. California leaders do not seem to be buying it:

On Monday, Mr. Trump said that the protesters in Los Angeles “are insurrectionists,” appearing to adopt a rationale that could allow him to invoke the 1807 Insurrection Act and use active-duty U.S. military personnel to deal with protests.

California’s Democratic leaders have blasted Mr. Trump’s moves, saying that the order to deploy the National Guard was unnecessary and an inappropriate use of power, while urging protesters to remain peaceful.

In an interview with The New York Times on Monday, Mr. Newsom said the decision to send the Marines to Los Angeles was “intended to sow more fear, more anger and to further divide.”

Appearing on CNN on Monday morning, Ms. Bass, the mayor, said that on “a few streets downtown, it looks horrible,” but that there was “not citywide civil unrest.” She added that anyone who destroyed cars or engaged in violence would be prosecuted.

Perhaps the question of the moment is one reflected in a Reuters headline: "Does US law allow Trump to send troops to quell protests? Dietrich Knauth writes:

President Donald Trump deployed National Guard troops to California after days of protests by hundreds of demonstrators against immigration raids, saying the protests interfered with federal law enforcement and framing them as a possible “form of rebellion” against the authority of the U.S. government. Defense Secretary Pete Hegseth on Monday mobilized 700 active duty Marines as part of the government’s response to the protests.

California sued the Trump administration on Monday to end the "unlawful" deployment of troops in Los Angeles County and return the state National Guard to California Governor Gavin Newsom's command.

 WHAT LAWS DID TRUMP CITE TO JUSTIFY THE DEPLOYMENT?

Trump cited U.S. Code Title 10, Sec. 12406, a federal law that outlines the role of the U.S. Armed Forces, in his June 7 order to call members of the California National Guard into federal service. A provision of Title 10 - Section 12 - allows the president to deploy National Guard units into federal service if the U.S. is invaded, there is a “rebellion or danger of rebellion” or the president is “unable with the regular forces to execute the laws of the United States.”
 
WHAT ARE NATIONAL GUARD TROOPS ALLOWED TO DO UNDER THE LAW CITED IN TRUMP'S ORDER?
 
An 1878 law, the Posse Comitatus Act, generally forbids the U.S. military, including the National Guard, from taking part in civilian law enforcement.
Section 12406 does not override that prohibition, but it allows troops to protect federal agents who are carrying out law-enforcement activity and to protect federal property. 
For example, National Guard troops cannot arrest protesters, but they could protect U.S. Immigration and Customs Enforcement who are carrying out arrests.
 
What is the gist of the Posse Comitatus Act? This is from an article at the Brennan Center for Justice: 

WHAT DOES THE POSSE COMITATUS ACT SAY?

The Posse Comitatus Act consists of just one sentence: “Whoever, except in cases and under circumstances expressly authorized by the Constitution or Act of Congress, willfully uses any part of the Army or the Air Force as a posse comitatus or otherwise to execute the laws shall be fined under this title or imprisoned not more than two years, or both.”

In practice, this means that members of the military who are subject to the law may not participate in civilian law enforcement unless doing so is expressly authorized by a statute or the Constitution.  

That seems straightforward enough, but the Reuters article shows there are other issues to consider. Dietrich Knauth writes:

WHAT DOES CALIFORNIA'S LAWSUIT SAY?

California's lawsuit said the deployment of troops in the state without the governor's consent violates federal law and the U.S. Constitution's 10th Amendment, which protects states' rights. 
The state argues the deployment does not meet any of the requirements in Title 10 because there was no “rebellion,” no "invasion" and no situation that prevented the enforcement of U.S. laws in the state.

Trump also did not consult with Newsom before deploying the National Guard, violating Section 12406's requirement that orders to deploy the National Guard "shall be issued through the governors of the States," according to the lawsuit.

 WHAT IS THE LAWSUIT ASKING FOR?

The lawsuit seeks a declaration from the court Trump's order is unlawful and an injunction blocking it from being enforced.

 HOW MIGHT A COURT VIEW THE DISPUTE?

There is little precedent for such a dispute. Section 12406 has only been invoked once to deploy the National Guard, when President Richard Nixon called upon it to deliver the mail during the 1970 Postal Service Strike, according to Bonta. 
Five legal experts from both left- and right-leaning advocacy organizations cast doubt on Trump’s use of Title 10 in response to the immigration protests and called it inflammatory and reckless, especially without Newsom's support.
The protests in California do not rise to the level of “rebellion” and do not prevent the federal government from executing the laws of the United States, experts said. 
Legal experts were split on whether a court would back Newsom’s interpretation of the governor’s role under Section 12406. 
Courts have traditionally given great weight to the word “shall” in interpreting other laws, which supports Newsom's position that governors must be involved in calling in the National Guard. But other experts said the law was written to reflect the norms of how National Guard troops are typically deployed, rather than giving a governor the option to not comply with a president's decision to deploy troops.

WHAT OTHER LAWS COULD TRUMP INVOKE TO DIRECT THE NATIONAL GUARD OR OTHER U.S MILITARY TROOPS?

Trump could take a more far-reaching step by invoking the Insurrection Act of 1792, which would allow troops to directly participate in civilian law enforcement, for which there is little recent precedent. 
Senior White House officials, including Vice President JD Vance and senior White House aide Stephen Miller, have used the term "insurrection" when discussing the protests, but the administration has stopped short of invoking the act thus far. 
It has been used by past presidents to deploy troops within the U.S. in response to crises like the 1794 Whiskey Rebellion and the rise of the Ku Klux Klan in the immediate aftermath of the American Civil War. The law was last invoked by President George H.W. Bush in 1992, when the governor of California requested military aid to suppress unrest in Los Angeles following the trial of Los Angeles police officers who beat Black motorist Rodney King. 
But the last time a president deployed the National Guard in a state without a request from that state's governor was 1965, when President Lyndon Johnson sent troops to protect civil rights demonstrators in Montgomery, Alabama.

 WHAT ABOUT THE MARINES?

Trump has more direct authority over the Marines than the National Guard, under Title 10 and in his constitutional role as commander in chief of the armed forces, legal experts said. 
But unless Trump invokes the Insurrection Act, the Marines are subject to legal restrictions that prevent them from taking part in "any search, seizure, arrest or other similar activity." The Defense Department said on Monday that the Marines were ready to support the National Guard's efforts to protect federal personnel and federal property in Los Angeles, emphasizing the relatively limited scope of their role at the moment.

Let's return to the Reuters question of the moment: Does U.S. law allow Trump to send troops to quell protests?

We have highlighted in blue the sections above that address that question. Here is a brief summary of what those sections tell us:

(1) The Posse Comitatus Act is clear: Members of the military who are subject to the law may not participate in civilian law enforcement, unless doing so is expressly authorized by a statute or the Constitution;

(2) California's lawsuit is clear:

a. The deployment of troops in the state without the governor's consent violates federal law and the U.S. Constitution's 10th Amendment, which protects states' rights; 

b. The deployment does not meet any of the requirements in Title 10 because there was no “rebellion,” no "invasion" and no situation that prevented the enforcement of U.S. laws in the state.

c. Trump  did not consult with Newsom before deploying the National Guard, violating Section 12406's requirement that orders to deploy the National Guard "shall be issued through the governors of the States."

d. The lawsuit, of course, has not been decided, but the legal holdings noted above indicate the people of California and their leaders are on solid footing.

(3) Legal experts from both left- and right-leaning advocacy organizations cast doubt on Trump’s use of Title 10 in response to the immigration protests and called it inflammatory and reckless, especially without Newsom's support.

The protests in California do not rise to the level of “rebellion” and do not prevent the federal government from executing the laws of the United States, experts said. In short, they agreed with language in the California lawsuit.
 
(4) The Marines are subject to legal restrictions that prevent them from taking part in "any search, seizure, arrest or other similar activity." That means the Marines role is so limited they might as well not be there. It suggests Trump is using the Marines mostly as a scare tactic and a chance to establish his "tough guy" bona fides. In other words, it's a huge waste of taxpayer resources, especially from a president who has taken a hatchet to the lives of federal workers and the expertise of federal agencies, supposedly in the name of cutting the U.S. deficit. Does Trump really care about the deficit? The answer appears to be no. Trump, we've learned, likes to glorify Trump, and his profligate spending of government funds to make abusive use of the Marines reflects a president with narcissistic tendencies. Also, he does not seem to care about public safety. And as we saw on Jan. 6, Trump's poor judgment led to serious injuries, even death. We fear the same thing could happen in Los Angeles.

Friday, December 15, 2023

Prelude to Justice: In the wake of roiling scandals, Southern Company execs are under the gun, and that includes former Alabama Power CEO Mark Crosswhite

Attorney Burt Newsome and family
 

Signs are increasingly pointing to the likelihood that Southern Company and its affiliates, which include Alabama Power, will be held accountable for a series of underhanded actions that apparently were designed to intimidate individuals who had taken action -- in court or the media -- to expose scandals swirling around the giant, Atlanta-based utility conglomerate. That is a key takeaway in a post yesterday at banbalch.com from K.B. Forbes, publisher of the Ban Balch blog and CEO of its parent organization -- the CDLU public charity and advocacy group.

Current and former Southern Company chieftains likely are feeling scandal-related stress, and that probably will not ease anytime soon -- as Forbes suggests under this headline: "A Year Later: A Prelude, Not an Aftermath, as Southern Company Faces the Music." From the post:

A year ago, the embattled CEO of Alabama Power Mark A. Crosswhite was ousted in disgrace. The surveillance efforts and scandalous acts of the Southern Company criminal enterprise were exposed in the public arena.

A few days after the announcement, we, the CDLU, received anonymously spreadsheets and documents outlining how Southern Company spent hundreds of thousands of dollars in the summer of 2020 attacking us, the family of our CEO, K.B. Forbes, and Burt Newsome and his family.

Both Forbes’ and Newsome’s young children were targeted and at times cried in fear by the foolish acts paid for by Southern Company.

 Southern Company’s campaign of fear and intimidation worked: The Forbes family fled their home, and Newsome had to hire and install new security and safety measures

 In recent days, speaking to insiders and seasoned law-enforcement officials, Crosswhite’s resignation was not an aftermath but a prelude of what is coming down the pike.

 Southern Company is facing the music.

 What points in that direction? Forbes provides details:

Last month, the whistleblower lawsuit filed in 2018 over Southern Company’s boondoggle Kemper Plant in Mississippi was unsealed.

It took 5 years for the big reveal, but the chickens have come home to roost.

Insiders and officials say that more federal probes are in the works, confirming what we wrote last month: “The Southern Company Criminal Enterprise is being held accountable, and the investigations currently under way are deep, massive in nature, and slowly coming together.“

Matrix LLC (and founder/owner Joe Perkins), Balch & Bingham, Alabama Power, and their goons appear to be in the middle of this firestorm.

Could Southern Company and affiliated entities soon be staring down the barrel of justice? Forbes' sources -- and he has followed the Southern Company scandals longer, and in more detail, than anyone -- say the answer is yes:

The Newsome Conspiracy Case, from a decade ago, ended with a $242,000 judgment against Burt Newsome, but cost Balch & Bingham between $40 and $100 million in clients and fees in the aggregate.
Now Balch’s sister-wife, Southern Company, may be on the hook for billions in fines, liabilities, and regulatory settlements for, in part, partaking in the foolish criminal acts against Newsome -- and his family -- that had no corporate purpose whatsoever.

We now ask Southern Company the same question we asked Balch: Have you lost your minds?

This story has tentacles that reach all the way to right-wing provocateur and Jan. 6 organizer Ali Alexander and to Colorado, where Alexander is the subject of a criminal complaint and investigation for alleged online solicitation of a minor. 

Alexander (formerly known as Ali Akbar before his criminal history became well known) was convicted in Texas of theft of property and credit-card abuse, both felonies, and he has a documented history of trolling online for gay sex. Alexander has longstanding ties to Alabama, and he and his National Bloggers Club (NBC) launched an intimidation campaign against me because someone who went by "RogerS"posted comments at a website the NBC bloggers  took as threatening, and they apparently became convinced I was "RogerS," even though I had nothing to do with the comments. Matt Osborne, publisher of the website where "RogerS" first appeared later stated that evidence showed I could not have been "RogerS." 

As for Burt Newsome, the nastiness against him includes a mysterious vehicle crash that shows signs of being staged and left him with a broken leg and other injuries. Will someone finally be held accountable for that, and other wrongdoing. K.B. Forbes' reporting suggests the answer is yes.

Tuesday, September 26, 2023

Trump, if re-elected, threatens to prosecute the media and his political enemies, a sure signal this guy is not mentally well and is unfit to serve in the office he seeks

Trump and Smudge, the cat of many memes
 

Donald Trump, if re-elected, is calling for his critics -- including media organizations and their employees, to be prosecuted for treason, according to a report at The New Republic. This came on the same weekend that Trump said Mark Milley, chairman of the Joint Chiefs of Staff and America's top military officer, deserves to be put to the death for treason. And it comes roughly one week after Trump said during a speech in South Dakota that, as president, he could prosecute his political enemies. 

If this does not convince Americans that Trump is mentally ill, dangerous, unfit to hold any public office (much less president), and -- to put it bluntly -- too ignorant to be allowed anywhere near the White House, it's hard to imagine what will.

It's hard to rank Trump's nutty statements, but for purposes of this post, we will stipulate that his threat to prosecute the media for engaging in Constitutionally protected speech (by, you know, the First Amendment) is No. 1. Of all people, a president should understand the rights to free speech and a free press; after all, it's called the First Amendment for a reason -- many scholars see it as the most important provision in our founding documents, a building block of what it means to live in our democracy. That Trump doesn't get that  indicates he is too dim-witted and hard-headed to serve in the office he seeks.

How alarming are Trump's statements of the past 8-10 days? The New Republic (TNR) gives an idea with this headline: "Trump Goes Full Deranged, Suggests Charging People He Doesn't Like With Treason." If that is not clear enough, TNR adds this sub-headline: "This is not a joke. Donald Trump is stating very plainly what he would do if re-elected." Torri Otten provides the appropriate tone with these words from an article dated 9/25/23:

Donald Trump went over the edge over the weekend and began calling for his detractors to be prosecuted or even put to death.

“They are almost all dishonest and corrupt, but Comcast, with its one-sided and vicious coverage by NBC NEWS, and in particular MSNBC, often and correctly referred to as MSDNC (Democrat National Committee!), should be investigated for its ‘Country Threatening Treason,’” he wrote on Truth Social Sunday night.

“I say up front, openly, and proudly, that when I WIN the Presidency of the United States … the LameStream Media will be thoroughly scrutinized for their knowingly dishonest and corrupt coverage of people, things, and events,” he said. “They are a true threat to Democracy and are, in fact, THE ENEMY OF THE PEOPLE! The Fake News Media should pay a big price for what they have done to our once great Country!”

Trump has never been a fan of news outlets that give him the slightest bit of negative or unbiased coverage. He even turned on his once-favorite Fox News after the network confirmed Arizona voted for Joe Biden in the 2020 election.

But the fact that he is threatening to censor news outlets through federal regulatory powers is terrifying, not to mention a huge violation of the Constitution.

Otten is right on target. That polls tell us large swaths of the American electorate do not grasp the reality that Donald Trump is a raving lunatic, and that he probably is incompetent to run a corner lemonade stand . . . well those folks could do us all a huge favor and stay at home on election day.

How does Trump con his MAGA followers into believing he actually is fit to serve as president? Consider his words above: "The LameStream Media . . . are a true threat to Democracy and are, in fact, THE ENEMY OF THE PEOPLE!" 

Psychologists call this "projection." Trump, of course, is the real threat to Democracy -- a genuine enemy of the people. But he uses projection to lull the MAGA crowd into a false sense of security, providing a distraction from the issues that really cause their fears and anxieties -- and confirms their prejudices. It's a subtle rhetorical device that essentially amounts to saying, "Hey, look over there. Those are your enemies." Trump makes regular use of projection, and it's a big part of his con-man act.

Let's return to Tori Otten's piece, where she provides background on Trump's recent ravings:

Trump’s threat to the news media was actually his second attempt to menace detractors this past weekend alone. On Friday, he slammed Mark Milley, the outgoing chairman of the Joint Chiefs of Staff, suggesting that perhaps he also committed treason.

“This guy turned out to be a Woke train wreck who, if the Fake News reporting is correct, was actually dealing with China to give them a heads up on the thinking of the President of the United States,” Trump said on Truth Social. “This is an act so egregious that, in times gone by, the punishment would have been DEATH!”

Trump was referring to two phone calls Milley made to Beijing, one during Trump’s last months in office and the second in the aftermath of the January 6 riot. The calls, which were to assure China that Trump was not planning to attack the country, were done at the direction of other Trump administration officials.

Trump, of course, appointed Milley to his role in 2018—but since then has repeatedly lashed out at the general. His Friday comments came after The Atlantic published a profile of Milley that described how he “protected the Constitution from Donald Trump.”

It should go without saying, but Trump making comments like this is incredibly dangerous. His followers have shown themselves quick to spring to action. Hundreds of January 6 defendants have said they descended on Washington because Trump personally called on them.

Republican lawmakers too quickly follow the former president’s commands. Another Trump supporter, Arizona Representative Paul Gosar, has also called for Milley to face death. In his newsletter Sunday, Gosar baselessly claimed that Milley and then–House Speaker Nancy Pelosi had worked to delay the National Guard’s response to the January 6 riot, to make Trump look bad.

“In a better society … General Milley would be hung,” Gosar wrote. “How this traitor remains in office is a question we need answered.”

(If it’s any consolation for Gosar, Milley retires on October 1.)

Gosar has shown himself remarkably willing to take up Trump’s call, even on the most extreme behavior. In December, Gosar posted on X, then called Twitter, backing Trump’s call to terminate the U.S. Constitution and overturn the 2020 election. He deleted the post an hour later, after it sparked backlash.

Gosar is the goofball that Stop the Steal organizer Ali Alexander claimed helped plan the Jan. 6 riots at the U.S. Capitol. Alexander has strong ties to Alabama, and at last report, was the subject of a police report in Colorado, alleging he had attempted to obtain "d--k pics" from teen boys. In a post dated 5/2/23, the communications manager for the Johnstown, CO, Police Department said the allegations against Alexander were under investigation. Our research indicates Alexander could face 2-6 years in prison and a $500,000 fine if prosecuted and convicted for "online solicitation of a minor" in Colorado.

On top of that, Alexander has a well-documented criminal history from the days when he was known as Ali Akbar. He also has a history of seeking gay sex via the Grindr online app.

(Note: I've included a meme of Trump and Smudge the Cat in an effort to add some levity to this post. But there is nothing amusing about the subject matter. If you are an American, Republican or Democrat, Trump is a threat to your way of life. I pray we get that before it's too late.)